PUNDIT ALERT! Obama and Predatory Credit Card Interest Rates

So far, Barack Obama's lack of full disclosure has gone unnoticed by the pundits jabbering about the Las Vegas Democratic debate last night.

The unpleasant truth is that Sen. Obama wasn't honest, in response to Tim Russert's question, in describing his entire voting history on the 2005 U.S. Senate bankruptcy bill.

Barack Obama "talked the populist talk" last night, lumping in credit card companies as targets of his economic rescue plans. But, in his first year in the U.S. Senate, Sen. Obama voted "Nay" on the Dayton Amendment to the 2005 bankruptcy bill that would freeze credit card interest rates at no higher than 30%. Obama sided with credit card companies over our nation's bedrock middle-class families as well as young adults susceptible to the companies' alluring, deceptive marketing.

That specific vote garnered Obama the admiration of his many corporate donors who find him "reasonable." After all, credit card companies comprise his second largest donor bloc. Harper's magazine noted in "Barack Obama Inc.: The birth of a Washington machine" that "it is also startling to see how quickly Obama's senatorship has been woven into the web of institutionalized influence-trading that afflicts official Washington. ..."

By the way, Sen. Hillary Clinton voted for the cap on predatory credit card interest rates.

Here's what Obama said last night in Las Vegas:

MR. RUSSERT: Senator Obama, the 2001 bankruptcy bill, the 2005 bankruptcy bill.

SEN. OBAMA: I opposed them both. I think they were bad ideas, because they were pushed by the credit card companies, they were pushed by the mortgage companies, and they put the interests of those banks and financial institutions ahead of the interests of the American people. And this is typical.

Now, Hillary's exactly right, but we've got to modify some of the fraudulent practices, predatory lending practices. I put in a bill a year and a half ago to make that happen because it does affect communities, including my own on the South Side of Chicago.

But unless we are able to rid the influence of special interest lobbies in Washington, we're going to continue to see bad legislation like that. And that's why we're going to have to change how politics is done in Washington.

Talk is cheap.

In "Obama Inc. vs. Working Families" on January 5, 2008, I quoted several corporate executives and top attorneys pleased with Obama's "Nay" on the anti-predatory-lending Dayton Amendment:

Barack Obama Sided with Credit Card Loan Sharks While Hillary Clinton Stood Against Them

Obama's numerous corporate donors were pleased -- especially The Bond Market Association's legislative affairs guy Mike Williams. While Obama voted against the 2005 bankruptcy bill, he voted against "an important amendment, which was defeated, that would have capped credit-card interest rates at 30 percent."

Williams was tickled that Obama stood up to those "consumer advocates" who work tirelessly to protect ordinary Americans aganst credit card usury:

"[Obama] studied the issue. ... Some assumed he would just go along with consumer advocates, but he voted with us on several points. He understood the issue. He wasn't closed-minded. A lot of people [especially those corporate lobbyists] found that very refreshing." -- "Barack Obama Inc.,"Harper's

Those predatory credit card companies constitute Obama's second biggest single bloc of donors.  From the Mother Jones article, "Campaign Contributions from Credit Card Companies? Priceless":

Obama, who made a strong floor speech in opposition to the 2005 bankruptcy bill, nonetheless voted against a key amendment that would have put a cap of 30 percent on interest rates. Financial firms, according to Ken Silverstein's much-discussed Harper's article "Barack Obama Inc.,""constitute Obama's second biggest single bloc of donors." You'll find nary a word about the debt crisis on his campaign web site.

You'll also want to check out David Sirota's retort to the Obama camp's uproar over a Washington Post story on the 2005 Bankruptcy bill: Obama Camp Feigns Outrage, Distracting From Obama's Vote to Allow Loan Sharking."

Here is one of Sen. Hillary Clinton's statements on predatory credit card lending practices:

"Statement by Hillary Clinton on Credit and Bankruptcy Concerns," November 25, 2007:

... "I will put an end to abusive practices by credit card companies that impose enormous fees and astronomical interest rates on unsuspecting borrowers. I will improve oversight of credit card lending policies, and vigorously enforce our laws against unfair and deceptive practices. I will change the bankruptcy rules that unfairly squeeze middle-class homeowners who have seen the value of their homes fall as their mortgage payments skyrocket. ..."

"Obama - Mr. Opportunity (return of the hollow man)" -- posted here at No Quarter on January 6th, author Wayne Williams reveals the misleading talk in Sen. Obama's campaign speeches:

Under the guise of being all things to all people, Mr. O is heartily solidifying corporate America's control of the political process in the name of - you guessed it, change. It's no surprise that clever advertisers have once again figured out how to sell the same ole - same ole as something new. Young Americans say that they are enthralled because Mr. O gives them hope.

I can appreciate the great appeal that Sen. Obama has for young people.

However, those young Americans should review the interest they're paying on their credit cards, and then ask themselves why Barack Obama backed credit card companies' predatory interest rates instead of protecting their financial futures.

Tags: Barack Obama, campaign finance, Credit Card Companies, Economy, Hillary Clinton (all tags)

Comments

21 Comments

Re: PUNDIT ALERT! Obama and Predatory Credit Card

I seem to recall that Obama's side of the story is that the Dayton amendment was poorly drafted and might have preempted some state consumer protection laws, etc.

I looked up the voting records and they were kind of inconclusive.  But there were definitely a few other good Democrats who voted against the Dayton amendment and also voted against the bankruptcy bill, just like Obama did, so maybe there's a reasonable case to be made.

by Steve M 2008-01-16 09:12AM | 0 recs
"Poorly crafted legislation"
is always his excuse.  Either voting record matters or it doesn't.
If it was poorly crafted then he has to make that case.  In the meantime he had a really stinky vote against protecting consumers from predatory credit practices.
by MollieBradford 2008-01-16 10:07AM | 0 recs
Re: PUNDIT ALERT! Obama and Predatory Credit Card

The amendment:

  SEC. __. TERMS OF CONSUMER CREDIT.

   (a) Cap on Interest Chargeable.--A creditor who extends credit to any consumer shall not impose a rate of interest in excess of an annual rate of 30 percent with respect to the credit extended.

   (b) Preemption of State Law.--The provisions governing rates of interest under subsection (a) shall preempt all State usury laws.

   (c) Exemption to Preemption.--If a State imposes a limit on the rate of interest chargeable to an extension of credit that is less than the limit imposed under subsection (a), that State law shall not be preempted and shall remain in full force and effect in that State.

It looks like it preempts, but only if the state law is weaker than the federal law.

But for obvious reasons, I'm hesitant to believe Susan's interpretation of this.

by Drew 2008-01-16 03:06PM | 0 recs
Re: PUNDIT ALERT!

Feedback and tips welcome!

by susanhu 2008-01-16 09:15AM | 0 recs
Great diary

You should post it elswhere as well as here and see what people think.

Don't expect the media to stop their starry eyed gazing at Obama long enough to cover such stuff.

by dpANDREWS 2008-01-16 09:17AM | 0 recs
Thanks again, Susan...

For exposing Obama's FULL RECORD on the 2005 Bankruptcy Bill. By then, Edwards was out of the Senate. And by then, Hillary had learned her lesson and voted right on the Dayton Amdt. AND the final bill. But what did Obama do in 2005? Oh, he just voted with the credit card companies to kill the amdt. that would have done something about these outrageous interest rates.

So much for populism...

by atdleft 2008-01-16 09:55AM | 0 recs
Re: And then he voted

Yeah! And he voted for Cheney's Iraq Invasion/Destruction Bill of 2002!

Oh wait...

by mcdave 2008-01-16 10:35AM | 0 recs
Re: Cherry picking? No rec for you.

Fact Check would find a problem with your selective Obama bashing.

Stacking the Deck
January 16, 2008

Dems deal misleading statements in Vegas debate.

Summary
The three leading Democratic presidential candidates debated in Las Vegas and we noted the following:

Clinton once again mischaracterized the 2005 energy bill, saying it had "enormous giveaways" to oil and gas companies. In truth, the measure raised taxes on those industries.

Obama accused the Bush administration of failing to make "any serious effort" to encourage use of alternative fuels or raise fuel efficiency of automobiles. In fact, President Bush has signed major bills that do both.

Edwards said he dropped his support for the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste storage site in part because of a scandal over forged documents. But he switched his position in 2004, and the scandal came along a year afterward.

The three candidates made sweeping claims about their intentions to remove troops from Iraq quickly, but all three admitted under questioning that they could have U.S. combat troops fighting in Iraq for years to come.

Clinton puffed up her role in stopping the "Bush administration" from taking back signing bonuses from those later wounded too seriously to complete their enlistments. Actually the Pentagon said its policy has been not to reclaim such bonuses and that a bill the Army sent to one soldier was an isolated case that was reversed.

Edwards said "you should learn to speak English" before becoming a U.S. citizen. In fact, the law already requires, with few exceptions, that applicants for citizenship "must be able to read, write, speak, and understand words in ordinary usage in the English language."

Note: This is a summary only. The full article with analysis, images and citations may be viewed on our Web site.


by shergald 2008-01-16 03:21PM | 0 recs
This was not just a cap on credit card

interest rates.  This would have capped payday loans as well, a.k.a. legalized loan sharks.

How much money has Obama raised from credit card and payday lenders?  Why isn't 30% enough for Obama?  

by Bear83 2008-01-16 05:05PM | 0 recs
PUNDIT ALERT!

susanhu, post this one on openleft and definitely kos. Excellent work!

by lonnette33 2008-01-16 09:53AM | 0 recs
The tactic you are using
is call inoculation.  Accuse your opponent of exactly what you are doing and you inoculate their charges against you.  
The links you site have no there there.  siting other blogs and internet sites that site other blogs and internet site is not good research.
You make outragous accusations with no back up.
for instance - "credit card companies are his second biggest donor block" - show me the proof.
This is an inaccurate and demagogic diary.
by Moonwood 2008-01-16 11:26AM | 0 recs
Re: The tactic you are using

IF you checked the sources, you'd see that most are from Harper's magazine and Mother Jones, as well as numerous other publications.  Harper's, Mother Jones, and David Sirota's blog are not exactly conservative publications.

Then there are the links to the U.S. Senate roll call.  No back-up indeed.  I'm laughing.

by susanhu 2008-01-16 01:10PM | 0 recs
Re: The tactic you are using

Also: I did link to my own story at NoQuarter.  But if you read that story, you will see that everything in that story is thoroughly vetted.

by susanhu 2008-01-16 01:15PM | 0 recs
Re: The tactic you are using

It is called blogging for Hillary. Obama bad is the message, true or not.

by shergald 2008-01-16 03:23PM | 0 recs
Re: The tactic you are using

You didn't answer my question - where is the link for the accusation that Obama second largest contributor bloc is from credit card companies?

by Moonwood 2008-01-16 04:24PM | 0 recs
Re: PUNDIT ALERT!

Yes, Obama DID vote AGAINST capping interest rates at 30%!!! 30%!!! I know this will not fit into the narrative Obama supporters so desperately want to believe but the truth is on Iraq, and the Bankrupcy Bill, Obama is NOT ONE SHRED better than Edwards or Clinton.

by RDemocrat 2008-01-16 12:13PM | 0 recs
You guys are unbelievable
You are actually trying to arm pundits with ways to attack Obama for votes that he didn't gives.
And you all call yourselves progressives?
Progressives don't eat their own, or throw their own under the pundit bus.
You all should be ashamed of yourselves.
by fetboy 2008-01-16 01:41PM | 0 recs
Re: You guys are unbelievable

Well, it's not clear to me that this is a vote that he didn't gives.  The diary makes a persuasive case that it's a vote he did gives.

by Steve M 2008-01-16 01:51PM | 0 recs
Steve

No reason to get nasty

by Moonwood 2008-01-16 04:25PM | 0 recs
Re: Steve

In response to a guy who says "you all should be ashamed of yourselves"?  Does your requirement of civil dialogue only apply in one direction?

by Steve M 2008-01-16 05:07PM | 0 recs
Re: PUNDIT ALERT! Obama and Predatory Credit Card

Yet Obama did vote against the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 which was a big boon to the credit card companies. To be fair, Clinton couldn't vote on it because Bill was in  the hospital for heart surgery.

Unless, you can point where the credit card legislation that you he didn't pass was not flawed in any way, you cannot fault him for voting no. Do you really want a president to pass bad legislation in order to seem like he is doing something about an issue?

by mothermaven 2008-03-11 07:12AM | 0 recs

Login

 

Sign-in-with-twitter-lighter

Advertise Blogads