From Eric Massa who is live blogging at kos right now!
If You Build it They Will Come...and Stay
After years of looking the other way as illegal immigration exploded, this Administration is manufacturing yet another crisis to divert attention from its multitude of failures, particularly in Iraq. While we all agree that illegal immigration is a problem - a major one at that - the President and the Republican congress are jumping the gun with knee-jerk, half-baked "crisis" solutions to a problem that has been building for years. And their "solutions" won't even begin to solve the problem, which has become institutionalized at multiple levels in our society, especially the economy itself.
I'll explain myself more in a moment, but right now, here's a summary of what I see as the important points about this "crisis."
::
1.
The Bush Double Flip. Back in 2005, Congress authorized 2,000 extra border patrol agents for each of the next five years - agents one would assume would actually be used to
patrol the border - but President Bush decided not to send all those extra agents. (
link) Now, he says "send in the guard" - itself an idea riddled with problems (more below). The first solution makes more sense, but the double flip illustrates the real Bush/Republican attitude: they're more interested in the politics than anything else.
2. "Send In The Guard" is a really dumb idea. What Guard? Almost all the National Guard is already tied down in that quagmire in Iraq. The idea that they can do this enormous, long-term job during annual two-week training stints, is a bad joke.
3. It's all about Economics. There are fundamental, structural issues of economics that are the real drivers of this "crisis," and any solution that doesn't deal with this won't work. Workers enter this country illegally because there is a demand for their services: cheap labor, no benefits. And it's not just businesses and corporations that like it this way. I don't hear any calls from the anti-immigrant crowd for boycotts of goods that we get more cheaply because they're produced with illegal labor - say, fruits and vegetables.
4. Secure the Borders. I believe that our first priority is to secure our borders. In a post-9/11 world, we simply must have control over who comes and goes, and why. But we can do it smart. We can't afford to shoot ourselves in the foot in the process. Security has to come hand-in-hand with a sane approach to the complex political and economic problems of the economic demand for immigrant labor, and the understandable desire of immigrants for the opportunity for a better life.
5. Talk about Border Security -- What about the Ports??? The fact that American ports are still 95% unprotected - an enormous gaping hole in our national security - tells the whole story about this Administration's commitment to national security, and to border security. This new crisis is mostly a red-herring - a stinky fish tossed into the middle of the room to distract us from the real story and the real agenda and the real failures of this Administration and its rubber-stamp Republican Congress.
There's more...