False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Former Virginia governor Doug Wilder is playing the race card by twisting the words of former President Bill Clinton completely out of context.  He insists on pretending that when Bill Clinton said Obama's record on the Iraq War was a fairytale that what he was really talking about was Obama's candidacy itself and not his record on the Iraq War. (link)
"Barack Obama is not a fairy tale. He is real," former Virginia Gov. L. Douglas Wilder told reporters at a Democratic fundraiser as the former president spent the day campaigning for Hillary Rodham Clinton in Richmond and three other Virginia cities.

Donna Brazile (and yes I know she is publicly "uncommitted" but she is smart enough to know that is not what Bill Clinton meant, so don't even pretend with me she didn't say that to help Obama) and Michelle Obama (also more than smart enough to know that is not what Bill Clinton meant since she graduated from Harvard Law School) made this same specific false charge about the use of the word "fairytale" before the South Carolina primary. (link)

It is also important to note that Senator Obama's campaign has pushed this same false charge before.  Here is documentation of a memo from a previous primary (link):

Sen. Barack Obama's presidential campaign has prepared a detailed memo listing various instances in which it perceived Sen. Hillary Clinton's campaign to have deliberately played the race card in the Democratic primary.

The document provides an indication that, in private, the Obama campaign is seeking to capitalize on the view - and push the narrative - that the Clintons are using race-related issues for political leverage. In public, the Obama campaign has denied that they are trying to propagate such a perception, noting that the document never was sent to the press.

In the memo, the Obama campaign highlights these "fairy tale" remarks and notes that Donna Brazile, Al Gore's 2000 campaign manager, "lashed into Bill Clinton" for them. The Clinton campaignhas said that the former president was referring to Obama's position on the Iraq. And indeed, Clinton made his remarks in the context of discussing criticism of the war.

Before the South Carolina debate Senator Obama publicly denied that his campaign was pushing the narrative that the Clintons were using race-related issues for political leverage.  But during the debate Tim Russert cornered him with a copy of the abovementioned memo and he was forced to admit that his team actually had been pushing that narrative.  Video of that exchange between Obama and Russert can be seen here.  

What makes me angriest about this is that for someone like Senator Obama, who does truly have the capability to transcend race, it is selling him short to deceive people, through playing the race card, into voting for him merely because he is black. This dishonest playing of the race card does nothing to promote Barack Obama's strongest points and in the end it is a disservice both to Senator Obama and to former President Bill Clinton.

Yesterday I addressed similar BS from Obama supporter Frank Rich who even went as far as to claim that Senator Clinton's Town Hall on Hallmark was racist. (link) Today I call upon Obama supporters everywhere to reject these false charges of racism that will taint the likely Obama victories in Virginia and DC and Maryland on Tuesday.

There are definitely other actions by supporters of Senator Clinton that could more legitimately be taken as demeaning and possibly racist, particularly the cocaine comment by Mark Penn.  And many would say the mention of Jesse Jackson by former President Clinton was race-baiting, though I would disagree with that particular comment being racist. (See comments here) Jesse Jackson himself said he did not find it offensive.

But instead of the instances that might legitimately be taken as racist, it is this particular comment that Governor Wilder is latching onto in the quote given above that has repeatedly been used as an  example of race-baiting by various supporters of Senator Obama.  This is because it sounds worse than any of the other comments when taken out of context.  Taken in context, it was not racist at all.  And to make charges of racism based on that particular comment is dishonest and inflammatory.  And it seems clear that Senator Obama's supporters are trying to intentionally inflame African Americans to get them to vote for Senator Obama.

Tags: L. Douglas Wilder, race-baiting (all tags)

Comments

32 Comments

It's swiftboating. Seriously.

The Obama campaign is taking a statement/words and rephrasing them and linking them to a racist implication, and now they will repeat it over and over and over to every African American audience they can find.  A classic case of swiftboating!

Thank you for the evidence to prove the memo that was sent out and acknowledged/approved by Obama himself.  I had heard about it, but was not sure it was real.

Reality bites, doesn't it?

by Shazone 2008-02-11 03:44AM | 0 recs
I never thought of it that way...

But you're right: They are swiftboating Bill & Hillary. Every time Team Obama twists the "fairy tale" statement (clearly about O's Iraq record) to mean something it doesn't (add racial subtext), they're engaging in swiftboating. Every time they accuse the Clintons of wanting to "take away our hope and our dreams" (again, adding nonexistent racial subtext), they're swiftboating. It's truly sad that Obama thinks using this Republican tactic is how to get the Democratic nomination.

by atdleft 2008-02-11 05:05AM | 0 recs
Perfect examples.

Swiftboating, pure and simple.

Also very deadly.  And very sad.

by Shazone 2008-02-11 06:02AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Well, this wins something in the short-term, but the exit polls already are pointing toward it having a damaging effect on his electability among white and latino voters.

by Jerome Armstrong 2008-02-11 03:46AM | 0 recs
Sad, but true...

You nailed it, Jerome! Not only is this campaign tactic morally questionable, but it's not even all that practical either. While Obama got a short-term boost out of it by winning South Carolina and later Deep South February state primaries, this may cause Obama future headaches in the general election. Already in the primary, voters are splitting along racial lines. And already, I'm hearing "chatter" from party insiders in my area about Obama having a HUGE problem with Latino voters in the general. For the good of our party, this race-baiting needs to stop!

by atdleft 2008-02-11 05:11AM | 0 recs
The more Obama camp play the race card

the more it might hurt him in GE.  

But he is smart, he never say it by himself.  But he uses his agent, Michelle and other surrogate to trumpet the race issue.  Maybe his strategy will work out.  who knows.  

by JoeySky18 2008-02-11 03:49AM | 0 recs
Drinking the sand....

This comment was posted yesterday by arkansasdemocrat and I am quoting it here because I believe it explains something very dangerous.  The Obama "Movement" is obviously willing to go to any length for their candidate....including swiftboating.  But if you own a movement you had better be able to control your followers and accept responsiblity for any damage it does.

As I wrote yesterday in "Do Unto Others", this is very dangerous territory.  The Repug war against Obama is going to be very very bad - for this country and our political system (IMHO)
arkansasdemocratic said (in part):

"What I mean is this: Obama refers to his candidacy as a movement. Usually movements are about something. The civil rights movement, the womens' movement, etc. had / have tangible and acheivable goals. The Obama "movement" seems to be mostly about Barack Obama. He seems to me to be using the Democratic party as a platform for his own ambition. I don't perceive Obama as a "real" Democrat. His stances on health care, his spewing of right wing critiques of universal coverage health care plans, his cavorting with homophobic ministers in the South are examples of his inferiority on the matter of being a committed Democrat seeking the Democratic nomination for President.

This is shocking. I see the Obama campaign as a stunning and alarming example of groupthink, which makes me very uncomfortable. Obama gives the masses little chunks of gristle to cling to- "hope" "togetherness" "a new way"- without really talking about what he wants to acheive in policy terms as President. He's been running for
President, quite successfully, for over a year now, and I still don't see the "there" there.
.........
There is a line in The American President that to me is emblematic of the Obama campaign: "People drink the sand because they don't know the difference."

by Shazone 2008-02-11 03:52AM | 0 recs
Yes

It's really annoying that major Obama supporters/endorsers are still pushing this.

When you look at the fairytale comment in context, it is obvious that Bill Clinton was talking about Obama's Iraq war stance/actions, and in particular the media reporting of it.

Bill Clinton has clarified on several occasions that he was in no way referring to Obama's career or candidacy it self.

Yet, Obama surrogates have continued to push this. There's no way they have not read the context or Clinton's clarification by now.

by Frank 2008-02-11 04:29AM | 0 recs
Thanks for illuminating what I've known all along

The media ran away with wanting to paint or smear the Clintons as being "racist" last month on the run-up to SC. And it was media alone that stirred the race waters following Clinton's stunning win in NH (ie harping on the Bradley effect). After Clinton's other upset in the Nevada caucus it was the "latinos are racist" meme.

And poor Bill Clinton, every strong word that came from his mouth trying to support his wife was twisted way out of context, and the AA community has had their sensitive racial sensibilities stoked by the Media. Once the media had the AA community on board in force believing the Clintons were evil, racist Klan members--it was on. Satellite radios and media airwaves had virtually every black leader up in arms over...what? a "fairytale" comment? Because Bill referred to Obama as a "kid" in one speech? Give me a fucking break why don't you--Obama supporters and especially the AA comuunity better grow a thicker skin because this is nothing like what it will be in the gen against McCain should he clinch the nomination. The AA community has rallied behind Obama big time and it's here to stay.

Mission accomplished by MSM--Clintons all but destroyed and left in the toilet. If Obama wins...I'm bracing myself for one of the ugliest general elections imagineable.

by Mariel 2008-02-11 04:47AM | 0 recs
Oh, and yes, a polarizing general election, too

by Mariel 2008-02-11 04:52AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Lol. Where's the part about race?

by illlaw1 2008-02-11 04:50AM | 0 recs
Using a phrase that referred to the Iraq....

war and saying that Clinton used it to refer to Obama.  (What's a fairy tale about Obama...that an AA could think he can run for POTUS...which no Clinton has every said or suggested.)

PLUS, the memo that Obama knew about and acknowledged - a memo that indicates that the race card was being played.

by Shazone 2008-02-11 05:06AM | 0 recs
Re: Using a phrase that referred to the Iraq....

Was that to me? Where is the part where Wilder said anything or even implied anything about race? Is "fairytale" racial code like "shuck and jive" or something?

by illlaw1 2008-02-11 05:12AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

This is going to be very damaging to the party in the GE. When the process started, I didn't mind who won i would wholeheartedly support the other. I am a registered Independent African-American female from the latte crowd.

Apartfrom her articulation of the issues,couple things have placed me firmly in the HRC column:
   1. Michelle Obama's claim that she didn't know if she could support HRC's candidacy, after HRC actively campaigned and fund-raised for her husband in 2004.
    2. BHO's claim that he can get HRC's voters, but he didn't know about the other way around.

The Jefferson Jackson dinner is just the last straw. I listened to HRC make a magnanimous party speech, and he and his backers turned it into his rally.

I will not vote for John McCain, and I will not stay home if Obama wins, I'll just vote for the candidates down the ticket and not cast a vote for president.

by LadyEagle 2008-02-11 05:13AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

This is an example of exactly the same tactic you are complaining about.  What Michelle said was she wasn't sure if she would work for HRC, not whether she would support her.  And considering she has a job and two small kids and is not the candidate, it is understandable.  And then Barack's claim about voters is HRC will not get the Independent support he gets, not his democrat supporters.  So if you're going to get so upset about Wilder, try not doing the same thing yourself.

by Piuma 2008-02-11 06:03AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Actually if you listen to the question and Bill Clinton's reponse you know that what he was calling a fairy tale is Barack Obama's judgement and rationale for Obama's candidacy.  So yes he was implying that Obama's run for president was not grounded in reality.

by afr114 2008-02-11 05:20AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

I know it exists and I watched it.

"But since you raised the judgment issue, let's go over this again.

That is the central argument for his campaign. '
It doesn't matter that I started running for president less a year after I got to the Senate from the Illinois State Senate. I am a great speaker and a charismatic figure and I'm the only one who had the judgment to oppose this war from the beginning. Always, always, always.' "

"First it is factually not true that everybody that supported that resolution supported Bush attacking Iraq before the UN inspectors were through. Chuck Hagel was one of the co-authors of that resolution. The only Republican Senator that always opposed the war. Every day from the get-go. He authored the resolution to say that Bush could go to war only if they didn't co-operate with the inspectors and he was assured personally by Condi Rice as many of the other Senators were. So, first the case is wrong that way."

"Second, it is wrong that Senator Obama got to go through 15 debates trumpeting his superior judgment and how he had been against the war in every year, numerating the years, and never got asked one time, not once, 'Well, how could you say, that when you said in 2004 you didn't know how you would have voted on the resolution? You said in 2004 there was no difference between you and George Bush on the war and you took that speech you're now running on off your website in 2004 and there's no difference in your voting record and Hillary's ever since?' Give me a break.

"This whole thing is the biggest fairy tale I've ever seen

So are you see the fairy tale is not just him being anti-war but also the rationale for him running for president.

by afr114 2008-02-11 05:46AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Give me a break...

by seattlegonz 2008-02-11 06:51AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Actually if you listen to the question and Bill Clinton's reponse you know that what he was calling a fairy tale is Barack Obama's judgement and rationale for Obama's candidacy.  So yes he was implying that Obama's run for president was not grounded in reality.

by afr114 2008-02-11 05:20AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

A majority of people listening to that comment would disagree with you I think.  But you are free to read it as you choose.

by Mike Pridmore 2008-02-11 05:56AM | 0 recs
Obama's trick that won't work in the general

If he were to  accuse McCain of being a racist McCain's numbers would go up not down.  Conservatives would say "hey maybe John really is one of us."

by dpANDREWS 2008-02-11 05:27AM | 0 recs
The Right Wing media and neocon GOP

(yes, those pesky neocons are still wielding their power) didn't pick this former naval aviator, POW war hero by accident. Obama's famous Iraq War speech  may not do him any good against McCain who's most certainly to run on a platform of hard national security credentials and the War against Terroism--a concern still registering high on the GOP electorate.

Hillary is better positioned to make the argument of being strong on national security. They won't be able to use the "Dems will get us blown up by terroists and raise your taxes" fear-mongering the right-wing Smearing Action Committee is posied to release on the public come the general.

by Mariel 2008-02-11 06:00AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

I don't see how Wilder's comments are race baitiing, unless Bill's were as well.  He is just taking Bill's word and turning them around for Barack's advantage.  This is something Obama has been extremely adept at doing which shows exactly how strong he is against attacks.  Hillary accused him in one of the debates as offering false hopes and said we need a reality check.  Barack now uses those exact words as a lead-in to the conclusion of his stump speeches: People say I'm peddling false hopes, I need a reality check, that I'm a Hopemonger...but let me tell you what hope is. I know what hope is because without hope I wouldn't be standing here today....

by Piuma 2008-02-11 06:08AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Lol. Where's the part about race?
I'm wondering the same. How did this get to be about race...simply because Obama's Black?

Bill used the phrase "fairy tale" in reference to Obama. Wilder fires back with "Barack Obama is not a fairy tale. He is real" and you call this race-baiting? Where's the part of Wilder's quote that involves race? As a supporter of Obama, I could see myself saying the same thing - that Obama is no fairy tale if someone connected Obama with that phrase in any manner.

If Obama wins...I'm bracing myself for one of the ugliest general elections imagineable.
Spare me. Considering that the GOP considers her the anti-Christ, nothing could possibly compare to the ugliness involved in a Hillary GE.

Is this just another useless Obama-bashing thread by Hillary supporters? Does the Obama-hatred increase the better that Obama does in the primaries and caucases? If so, it may get to fever-pitch on Wednesday depending on Tuesday's results.

Hey, this thing could easily drag out all the way to the convention so I guess we've got a bunch more months left to puke on each other - definitely the "Democratic" way.

by desertjedi 2008-02-11 06:09AM | 0 recs
Right--exactly how they've gotten you to think

[Spare me. Considering that the GOP considers her the anti-Christ, nothing could possibly compare to the ugliness involved in a Hillary GE.]

My point exactly--hook, line...and sinker.

by Mariel 2008-02-11 06:30AM | 0 recs
my point being...nothing is more divisive

and polarizing in this country than Black/White Race relations and that wound's scab has been eagerly picked at by many in the media and Obama supporters. And now that the AA community and electorate is plugged in, the media more than ever is taking this practice to an extreme. I gave examples above but you're free to view this post any way you want and have your own read on things.

And speaking about hatred, no one does it better than you Obamaniacs--who dragged Hillary though the mud and Bill to advance your guy. never mind all they've done for the AA community thoughout the years. like I've been saying...what goes around comes around.

by Mariel 2008-02-11 06:27AM | 0 recs
Re: my point being...nothing is more divisive

True. I really wish that Obama supporters hadn't tried to paint the picture of Obama as a drug-dealing muslim who wasn't up for hard work and was just shucking and jiving his way through the election in a way that was reminiscent of Jesse Jackson and who could never win the Latino vote since Latinos, historically, don't vote for African-Americans. The divisiveness of all that was unnecessary.

Oh wait...

by illlaw1 2008-02-11 06:55AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

What's wrong in saying Obama's campaign is fairy tale and how is that race baiting? Isnt all fairy tales based on HOPE?

by Sandeep 2008-02-11 06:48AM | 0 recs
Bill C did not say...

...the campaign is a fairy tale..that's the point of the poster.

by demwords 2008-02-11 07:27AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Doug Wilder is utterly irrelevant. The only bright spot in an Obama candidacy is that this is the last time African-American voters will have any significant power within the Democratic party. A new coalition of "browns" comprised mainly of Latinos and Asians in key Western and East coast states will play a major role in this upcoming election and will check mate whatever power is left among African-Americans. From here on in, African-Americans will have to fit into the brown coalition or suffer slow sclerosis of power. Ironically, voting for a "black" president as a purely symbolic gesture, will only highlight the powerlessness of African-Americans to effect real concrete change.  "You have the first black president, what more do you want?" will be the taunt from others should African-Americans mistake their symbolic act for the promise of actual reform.

Either way the brown coalition of Latinos and Asians wins, they can either throw the election to McCain and make their power felt, or make Obama kneel before them and extract all sorts of deals to make him president in a way that African-Americans, who have readily given up their vote without extracting meaningful concrete deliverables from Obama, can't. Doug Wilder represents the last gasp of declining African American electoral power that has been so grossly mismanaged by his brand of short-sighted symbolically-based leadership of first this and that. Its a shame Wilder has to take it out on Clinton of all people.

by superetendar 2008-02-11 08:23AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

Somebody should remind Gov. Wilder and the MSM, that Jesse Jackson and Rep. John Lewis has stated that nothing said by Bill Clinton had any racial overtones.

by wdking 2008-02-11 08:25AM | 0 recs
Re: False Charges of Race-Baiting by Doug Wilder

THANK YOU for this! I had read the comments from Gov. Wilder yesterday, and had to wonder if he was purposefully being dishonest about this, or if he somehow really believed that the Clintons became racists overnight.  

Shame on him for contorting their words.  I watched the clip of Bill Clinton, and he was absolutely talking about Obama's history of supporting or not supporting the war.  Also, how is it that Obama did a stand-up comedy routine making fun of Hillary, but every word by the Clintons or their staff or supporters is combed through for anything that can be construed as negative.  A shameful double-standard.

by Catriley sez 2008-02-11 09:23AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------