First, stylistically, I think everyone can agree, even the most rabidly partisan -- McCain stank up the stage. SO, there's that.
But McCain's personal pronoun ration was baffling. If it had been a drinking game, I'd have been wasted within 5 minutes and dead by the end.
Honest to god, this was my first impression, true -- but after several repeat viewings, it got WORSE.
I am a rabid partisan, it is true; but I am also known among some pretty partisan REPUBLICAN observers as someone who will tell the truth when it counts -- when it HURTS... this was shockingly replete with personal pronouns.
As for analysis of policy and vision -- well, there are better people for that, and I think we've seen the results coming in -- it's not pretty.