HOUSE RATINGS: Democrats poised to keep their majority

The beginning of the month brought the Senate rankings. Two weeks have passed, so it is time to look at the picture in the House. As bad as this week was for the GOP on the Senate (and make no mistake about it, between Hagel's retirement and Warner and Shaheen jumping in the race, this was as bad as it can get), House Republicans did their best to beat that. After a month of recruitment failures and retirement announcements, Republicans are not at their best in House races, and while some of them were hoping that they could reconquer the House in November 2008, that looks increasingly unlikely.

Read full ranking at Campaign Diaries.

It is naturally very early to tell where most of these races are headed. House contests develop much later than Senate ones. On the Senate side, most Senators are nearing announcements about whether they will run again, and most challengers have already taken steps towards launching their campaign. But on the House side, the recruitment drive is only starting and many more retirements are still expected.

It is however a good exercise to rank these races, see which ones are already in play, which ones are gearing up to be the most competitive of the next cycle, and where the challenging party really hasn't gotten its act together. The overall picture favors Democrats: They are defending no competitive open seats, have put together some good challengers, and are benefiting from the national environment. Many Republicans who barely survived in 2006 are now being targeted, and races that were under-funded then will be treated as top-notch opportunities next year.

But Republicans also have a lot of opportunities: Of the 31 freshmen democrats who picked-up GOP seats last fall, many hold very red districts that are likely to vote even more Republican in a presidential year. Many are already being put to the test, and Republicans are claiming some recruitment victories (CA-11 or CT-5). But the GOP will have to work hard to put all the seats it wants in play.

Outlook: 6-10 seat Democratic pick-up

Here is the description of only the first ten seats. Go here for the full rankings!

Republican seats, Lean take-over (4)

  • AZ-1 (Open): Ethically challenged Renzi's retirement gave Republicans a better shot at keeping the seat. But this is exactly the kind of scandal-tainted seat Democrats were so good at winning in 2006, so there is no reason to think they are not favored today.
  • CA-4 (Incumbent: Doolittle): This district is very heavily Republican and will favor the GOP in a heartbeat again if only FBI-investigated Doolittle gets out of the race. But he is claiming he will run -- and as long as he does Democrat Brown (who almost beat him in 2006) has a great shot.
  • OH-15 (Open): Pryce did not want to go through another nasty and close race and called it quits, and major Republicans (like former AG Petro) passed on the race since then. Meanwhile, 2006 Democratic nominee Kilroy has been campaigning for months and is likely to take away the district.
  • VA-11 (Likely open): Tom Davis is running for Senate, and his district is in blue-trending Northern Virginia. This is exactly the kind of place in which Virginia Democrats have been making huge progress in recent years. Nothing is set in stone until Davis runs, but a huge headache for the GOP.

Democratic seats, Lean take-over (1)
  • FL-16 (Rep. Mahoney): Foley's former seat, that Mahoney only won because of the page scandal. That Republicans only lost by one point under these as-bad-as-it-gets local circumstances shows that Mahoney is not that strong here. Republicans are happy with their candidates, and plan to use Mahoney's recent statements (such as one declaring that Congress "wasn't the greatest job") against him.
Republican seats, Toss-up (11)
  • CO-4 (Rep. Musgrave): Musgrave, best known for her obsession in the anti-gay marriage amendment, has been constantly under-performing in this district, and she won by a few points in 2006. Democrats did not pay that much attention to the race then, but they will this time. There is a primary between Angie Paccione (the 2006 nominee) and Betsy Markey (a former Salazar aide).
  • CT-4 (Rep. Shays): Shays survived two extremely close races in 2004 and 2006. This time, the candidate has changed and Jim Himes has been highly touted as the Democrat who will finally take out the last New England Republican. Shays is also threatening to resign or retire if leaders don't give him what he wants.
  • IL-10 (Rep. Kirk): Netroots favorite Dan Seals got 47% in 2006, and is back for a rematch. IL-10 was on few people's watchlist in 2006 but this is the kind of district the DCCC will go after this time around.
  • NC-8 (Rep. Hayes): Hayes won by a few hundred votes in 2006 against a Democrat to whom no one in DC was paying attention, and who received no funding from the DCCC. This time, Kissel has everyone's attention and will get help from the national party. But Hayes, who was caught off-foot in 2006, will be prepared too.
  • NM-1 (Rep. Wilson): One of the closest races in 2006. Wilson thought her streak of victories against highly-touted Democrat would allow her to get a pass in 2008, but that was before the attorney scandal put her at the heart of an ethics controversy.
  • OH-1 (Rep. Chabot: Chabot has always been in close races, and he surprised many by winning his 2006 race. Like every cycle, Democrats vow that they finally have the solution and will take Chabot down.
  • OH-2 (Rep. Schmidt): A very red district, but Schmidt barely won a 2005 special election against Hackett before winning by a similarly small margin in 2006. She will also probably face a serious primary challenge. It is clear voters do not like Schmidt, and Democrats will try to take advantage.
  • OH-16 (Rep. Regula): Regula is on the brink of retirement, and both parties are ready to run a competitive open seat.
etc...!

Read the rest of the rankings (there are still plenty of seats described in detail and rated!) at "Campaign Diaries.

(Sorry for the shameless partial posting and linkage to Campaign Diaries, I am just trying to get people to come check out my website, because it's starting to look really good! So come and read CampaignDiaries.com!)

Tags: AZ-1, CA-4, CO-4, CT-4, FL-16, House ratings, IL-10, NM-1, OH-15, VA-11 (all tags)

Comments

7 Comments

tips!

by LeftistAddiction 2007-09-15 02:11PM | 0 recs
IL-10

This is the district that I grew up in - northwest and northern suburbs of Chicago.  IL-8, Melissa Bean's district, is much more rural, and covers the area east of IL-10 to the lake and north the IL-WI border.

IL-10 should be Dem.  If IL-8 is Dem, IL-10 MUST be Dem.

Not only is it suburban and increasingly purple, but various parts are HEAVILY Spanish - Des Plaines is very spanish these days.  

I will make a contribution to Mr. Seals.

by dataguy 2007-09-15 02:22PM | 0 recs
to keep their majority

Something worth noting is that Mahoney is one of the best fundraisers for his campaign.  If anyone can hold that seat, it is going to be him.  

by JeremiahTheMessiah 2007-09-15 05:18PM | 0 recs
Re: to keep their majority

best fundraisers for house freshman

by JeremiahTheMessiah 2007-09-15 05:20PM | 0 recs
Re: HOUSE RATINGS: Democrats poised to

I honestly expect that there will an increase in the number of 3rd parties or ind holding seats in congress after the 2008 election.

by orin76 2007-09-15 05:21PM | 0 recs
Re: HOUSE RATINGS: Democrats poised

DON'T FORGET ABOUT NV-03!!    It is THE pickup opportunity in the Southwest.

Jon Porter [R] is the incumbent.  This is a suburban Las Vegas district that is 50/50 registration and it seems is finally trending more Democratic.  (In fact, I just moved into Porter's district myself!)

Tessa Hafen, the Dem who ran in 2006, lost by only 1%!  Now we have a hotshot Chief Deputy District Attorney jumping into the race to challenge Jon Porter.  He's handled almost all of the large court cases that people hear about in Southern Nevada.

However...

Jon Porter has the sleaziest ad team around.  His main consultant has even teamed up with the NRSC to take his sleaze nationally.  Porter simply parrots the conservative/Bush line, avoids the media, and wins by simply smearing his opponent into submission.  Hafen put up an admirable fight in 2006 and I hear that Hafen's campaign manager has joined Robert Daskas' 2008 campaign. :)  Don't forget about this race (as some more attention could have won it in 2006!)

by mbcarl 2007-09-15 11:58PM | 0 recs
CO-4 is one to watch!

CO-4 hasn't had a democratic primary since the 70's - this is huge.

The 2006 campaigns for this seat were ugly, on both Musgrave and Paccione.  Paccione did only lose by a marginal vote, but her name recognition remains unfavorable.  Betsy Markey is the candidate for this district, having been Salazar's Regional Director for this district, she knows the people's needs and desires better than Paccione.  Betsy is also more representative of the values of our district, whether red, blue or purple, than Angie is.  Betsy Markey is a proven leader who will represent tenaciously for a people that she believes in passionately.

by hamiam 2007-09-16 07:34PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------