Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

I had a feeling this would happen, but apparently the recent "reshuffling" of the Clinton campaign team - with Patti Solis Doyle stepping aside in favor of another longtime Clinton advisor Maggie Williams - is causing some tension among a Latino superdelegate and El Diario/La Prensa (described as "the largest and oldest Spanish-language daily newspaper in New York City, and the oldest Spanish-language daily in the United States.")

The e-mail from, Steven Ybarra, a California superdelegate who heads the voting-rights committee of the DNC Hispanic Caucus, was sent to fellow caucus members in the hours after word broke that Solis Doyle - the most prominent Latina in Clinton's campaign - would be replaced by another close Clinton loyalist, Maggie Williams, who is black.
______________________
The superdelegate, Steven Ybarra apparently wrote an email to several DNC colleagues.

Taken from http://www.nypost.com/seven/02122008/new s/nationalnews/super_latino_slams_clinto n_97237.htm

"The e-mail noted that Clinton, who is looking to Latino voters for a boost in the Texas and Ohio primaries on March 4, scored heavily with Hispanics in her California win.

"Apparently, loyalty is not a two-way street," he wrote. "Latino superdelegates like myself . . . will have cause to pause."

Ybarra told The Post yesterday that the loss of Solis Doyle, a child of Mexican immigrants, just weeks before the Texas primary, where 36 percent of the population is Hispanic, was "dumb as a stump." 

The Spanish language newspaper was not as tough, but still sounds like they're accusing the Clinton campaign of taking advantage of the positive news gained through publicizing in heavily Latino states that the manager was a fellow Latina.

_____________________

Taken from http://www.eldiariony.com/noticias/detai l.aspx?section=25&desc=Editorial& ;id=1811270

"Hillary Clinton's campaign is in trouble and the highest ranking Hispanic in her camp is paying the price. Campaign manager Patti Solis Doyle stepped down this weekend - after Barack Obama beat Clinton handily in four states scattered in different regions of the country.

Transitions happen in any campaign. And sometimes they work wonders. John McCain's camp underwent a revamp when his poll numbers cratered and his chances of winning the Republican nomination were written-off by the national media.

With Clinton's losing streak looking like it might extend all the way to March, the campaign probably had to project some internal shift - a fall-person, as it were, was needed. The irony is that back when Solis Doyle, the daughter of a Mexican immigrant who worked as a janitor in Chicago, came on board, she was celebrated as the first Hispanic woman to run a presidential campaign. One of the key constituencies that has actually turned out for Clinton is Hispanic voters. Indeed, Clinton's chances of winning the nomination may rise or fall on the Latino turn-out in the upcoming Texas primary. What effect Solis Doyle's resignation will have on Hispanic voters remains to be seen. But it cannot help.

There is an old saying from the factory floor - last hired, first fired. This practice is sadly well known to African Americans and Latinos, who have had to fight to gain access to jobs and opportunities, and struggle just as hard to hold on to them without the safety nets of a social network or seniority in status.

Clinton has worked hard for the Hispanic votes she has won so far in this tight race, and it would be a mistake to risk alienating that base."
_____________________

Looks like they're now throwing her under the bus. http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200802u/patti-solis-doyle

Tags: 2008, Hillary, Hispanic, latino, obama, texas (all tags)

Comments

14 Comments

Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

If you are gonna be in the Democratic Party you have got to learn to love this sort of identity politics!  No matter what you do, you're always pissing someone off.

Somehow, I doubt Latino voters will flee from Hillary as a result of this, any more than African-American voters will flock to her because the new campaign manager is black.  But I can hardly say I'm surprised that someone would make an issue of it.

by Steve M 2008-02-12 06:43AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

Why is EVERYTHING about race? I am a Latino and I can not care less about Patti Solis Doyle. I do not vote for Hillary because she hired some Latinos. I vote for her because she is a more qualified candidate. I truly regret that these primaries intensify racial divisions rather than minimize them. I am very disappointed.

by praxis1 2008-02-12 07:08AM | 0 recs
it's kind of sad in a way

Especially since she basically replaced one underrepresented minority with another - so it's not like someone could plausibly argue that she was getting rid of the brown and black people. I don't support Clinton, but I respect the fact that she has always stuck with her earliest supporters.

by highgrade 2008-02-12 07:14AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

It's not like Patti is gone. She is still a senior campaign advisor and personal advisor to Senator Clinton not to mention she will be traveling extensively with the campaign. Hillary thinks of Patti like a daughter.

People need to take a step back.

by americanincanada 2008-02-12 07:14AM | 0 recs
I'm not for HRC but I think this is actually a bit

unfair. The campaign has been run terribly and someone had to go. I don't think her replacement will be any better. The core strategy is a bad one.

A much more valid reason that Latinos shouldn't vote for her is her draconian immigration position for immigrants convicted of a crime. Shit happens but if it's not big shit then you shouldn't be torn from your family because of it after you already did your time. That's not our way.

by illlaw1 2008-02-12 07:21AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

I wondered how long it would take for Obama supporters to try and use Patti Solis Doyle to pinata Hillary. Sorry won't work your trying to play the Latino race card. The rise of Latino voting power in this election is more than about one person, it is about galvinizing their voting power and finally assuming their place ahead of African-Americans in the Democratic party.

The most perverse and sorry aspect of this whole election has been white limousine liberals playing the race card to the hilt by trying to manipulate the emotions of African-Americans and Latinos, especially if getting those Clintons is the aim. Latinos thankfully are less open to the being emotionally manipulated otherwise with  Richardson dropping out they would have just sat on their hands instead of voting for Hillary.

Let's face it, Obama's Latino problem has angered many limo liberals who thought they had figured out the black/white formula to beat Hillary. I know there is much frustration with this unexpected wrinkle. You can hear it every time some exasperated MSNBC talking head talks down to a Latino guest, with that "why can't you guys just vote for Obama" tone in the MSNBC hosts voice.

The Latino vote is not about race, it is about pure political power and if they have to vote McCain or stay at home to teach Democratic gringos a lesson, well thats what may well happen. A word of warning, Latinos are not like African-Americans, a ploy like this will likely blow up in Obama's face, so as helpful as you think you are being by planting this little racial poison pill, it may yet come back to haunt your little laboratory of ethnic conflict.

by superetendar 2008-02-12 07:24AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

It sounds like you are equally guilty of trying to make this a black vs. brown thing, with your comment about Latinos "assuming their place ahead of African-Americans in the Democratic Party."

I always thought the Democratic Party was supposed to be about inclusiveness, about giving everyone a seat at the table.  Why does there have to be only one minority seat that the African-Americans and the Latinos have to fight over?  Why is it so important that one group be "ahead" of the other?

What this little flap exposes is that when everything is about race, there is no way to win.  Imagine if a Democratic President trying to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court - if it's all about which ethnic minority gets to "win" by having one of their own appointed, there is no way to avoid having one winning group and a whole lot of losing groups, unless the nominee is Soledad O'Brien.  We'll never have a successful coalition if we keep playing the game this way.

by Steve M 2008-02-12 07:39AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

The Obama team plays the race card again...

Team Hillary says playing the race card will backfire on you.

Team Obama says why is this about race and tries to play their card again.

Team Obama is patently racist.

Obama is patently racist

Just look up his quotes

Just look up his pasters quotes

Why is racism tolerated if the racist is a minority?

by sonofdonkeykong 2008-02-12 08:05AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

Please kindly share a link that shows this is from "Team Obama".

Or if we're just working on innuendo on this side of the aisle I guess HRC is guilty of killing Vince Foster, is run by Communist China, and is a Whitewater crook.

Or maybe you're not from this side of the aisle...

by illlaw1 2008-02-12 09:26AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

I'm not saying that you're wrong but if you can show me the connection to the Obama camp that would be helpful.

by illlaw1 2008-02-12 07:42AM | 0 recs
hey

I am only relaying what was already reported, and even mentioned that I think it's unfair to be criticized for the change in personnel.

One thing that seems to be missed is that Patti was on her way out in early January, but was only saved by the NH miracle. So apparently this was contemplated way before the campaign moved into Super Tuesday etc - I think that is pretty good evidence that they aren't trying to scapegoat her for not winning this thing outright after 2/5.

Either way, I think this shows a minor example of what happens when you are associated too strongly with one constituency. I think that is one reason that Obama is trying so hard not to be typecast as the "black" candidate. Fact is that he's probably going to take some positions that may not be popular in the black community. I think recently the media story has been how dependent that Hillary has been on the Latino vote, and that can backfire if that constituency feels offended in some way.  

by highgrade 2008-02-12 08:42AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

i think this will fall on deaf ears

by sepulvedaj3 2008-02-12 07:43AM | 0 recs
Re: Hillarys's potential Latino(a) Problem

Hispanics don't care about Patti Solis Doyle. Frankly, I don't even know who works on Obama's staff (campaign manager etc) and i don't think the ordinary Hispanic does either.

"Oh, she fired a hispanic let me vote for Obama"

Ya. She's REALLLLYYY gonna suffer.

by falcon4e 2008-02-12 09:55AM | 0 recs
by highgrade 2008-02-12 11:49AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------