Death of the Center-Right Myth
by Dan Conley, Mon Nov 03, 2008 at 07:01:45 AM EST
How many times have we had the "center-right nation" maxim shoved down our throats over the past quarter century? Every Democratic win has been tempered by it. Every Republican defeat cushioned.
The problems with the harebrained theory are obvious ... first, it connotes a permanence that hasn't existed throughout American history. Was America a center-right nation during the New Deal? When Harry Truman won (despite two Democratic independent competitors) in 1948? When LBJ crushed Goldwater? Could a nation that elected a Democratic House for all but two years from 1932 to 1994 be considered center right?
So obviously, there was a time when what counts as an American Left held the power in our system. There has been an ebb and flow and will continue to be an ebb and flow.
But pundits keep returning to the Center-Right Myth (from here on called CRM) because Republicans promote it enthusiastically and consistently. They cite that only one Democratic Presidential candidate since World War II has topped 51 percent of the vote. They demean Democratic Congressional power over 62 years as proof of the power of Dixiecrats. They point to polls that show Democrats dying off every year, while conservatives dominate the 35 to 55 cohort.
After tomorrow, all of these data points will be invalid and the myth will be officially dead.
Obama will almost certainly top the Carter line ... more important, he'll bring millions of voters into the process. If they stay, the political equilibrium will tilt left with it.
Democrats will approach a filibuster proof majority in the Senate and a Blue Dog proof edge in the House. The Dixiecrats are not padding the lead this time, the South will remain solidly Republican and Conservative.
And most important of all, the new Democratic majority will not be forged by an aging, dying off generation, but by young voters who were disgusted by eight years of Bush failure and are now solidly in the Democratic camp. If we can keep their trust, they will form the core of a solid Democratic majority for years to come.
So are we now approaching a "permanent" liberal majority? Of course not. Still only about 22 percent of Americans self-identify as liberals. But that's roughly the situation conservatives faced in 1968. With success, people will slowly start to embrace the words liberal and progressive again. Even Republicans now see that they have to ratchet up the attacks to the insane level of socialist to get a rise out of swing voters. Now that conservative has been discredited, liberal isn't such a dirty word.
Tomorrow will be an important first step, one that must be reinforced day by day with good legislation, good judges and well-administered policies. Liberalism succeeds when Americans feel their faith in government restored. It won't happen overnight ... it's a process that will probably outlive the Obama administration.
But starting tomorrow, we have a chance to begin again ... the CRM is dead. Long live the New Liberal America.







