The Trouble With The Auto Bailout
by Todd Beeton, Fri Dec 19, 2008 at 08:24:03 AM EST
After the Republican Congress tried to kill an auto bailout, the Republican President has gone around them and approved $17.4b in loans from TARP to rescue the auto industry.
Citing danger to the national economy, President Bush approved an emergency bailout of the U.S. auto industry Friday, offering $17.4 billion in rescue loans in exchange for tough concessions from the deeply troubled carmakers and their workers.The government will have the option of becoming a stockholder in the companies, much as it has with major banks, in effect partially nationalizing the industry. [...]
Allowing the massive auto industry to collapse in the middle of what is already a severe recession cannot be allowed, Bush said.
"It would worsen a weak job market and exacerbate the financial crisis," he said. "It could send our suffering economy into a deeper and longer recession. And it would leave the next president to confront the demise of a major American industry in his first days of office."
Of course, they're still holding the auto industry to an entirely different standard than they held Wall St. to, i.e., suddenly there are conditions and strings in order for the auto industry to get the money:
Viability Requirement: The firms must use these funds to become financially viable. Taxpayers will not be asked to provide financing for firms that do not become viable. If the firms have not attained viability by March 31, 2009, the loan will be called and all funds returned to the Treasury.Definition of Viability: A firm will only be deemed viable if it has a positive net present value, taking into account all current and future costs, and can fully repay the government loan.
Binding Terms and Conditions: The binding terms and conditions established by the Treasury will mirror those that were voted favorably by a majority of both Houses of Congress...
Interesting that the fact that a majority of Congress voted for it is good enough to sell the President's plan, just not good enough to pass it. Got it.
But notice the further strings attached to this money, buried way down under the "Targets" section:
- Work rules that are competitive with transplant auto manufacturers by 12/31/09.
- Wages that are competitive with those of transplant auto manufacturers by 12/31/09.
Or, to put it more plainly, as Marcy Wheeler states bluntly:
The President of the United States just dictated that American corporations pay their employees significantly less than the employees of foreign owned manufacturers. And/or, he dictated that American corporations pick the pocket of their senior retirees.
This was always about union busting and in the hands of our current president, it still is. For now, President-elect Obama is on board with the plan:
"Today's actions are a necessary step to help avoid a collapse in our auto industry that would have devastating consequences for our economy and our workers," he said. "With the short-term assistance provided by this package, the auto companies must bring all their stakeholders together -- including labor, dealers, creditors and suppliers -- to make the hard choices necessary to achieve long-term viability."
But one hopes that once he is in office, perhaps after the March 31st deadline passes, that the loans can be restructured with an eye toward lifting up America's auto workers as well as the industry as a whole. Despite the mantra of conservatism for thirty years, the two goals are not mutually exclusive.






