Isikoff: Bush Won't Pardon Libby, Stevens

Michael Isikoff, in Newsweek:

In a move that has keenly disappointed some of his strongest conservative allies, President Bush has decided not to pardon Vice President Dick Cheney's former chief of staff, I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby, for his 2007 conviction in the CIA leak case, two White House officials said Monday.

On Bush's last full day as president, Bush did commute the sentence of two former Border Patrol agents--Jose Compean and Ignacio Ramos--for shooting a Mexican drug dealer and then lying about it. But White House press spokesman Tony Fratto told NEWSWEEK "you should not expect any more" pardons and commutations from Bush before he leaves office Tuesday. Another senior official, who requested anonymity discussing sensitive matters, confirmed that no more pardons would be granted.

Bush's decision leaves a long line of rejected pardon applicants, many of whom have retained politically well-connected Washington lawyers, to make their case for presidential mercy in Bush's final days in the White House. Among them were junk-bond king Michael Milken, media mogul Conrad Black, former Illinois GOP governor George Ryan and former Louisiana Democratic governor Edwin Edwards. Bush also apparently turned down a last-minute plea from Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski to pardon her former GOP colleague Ted Stevens for his recent political corruption conviction.

I must admit that this news surprises me, as I believed that George W. Bush was going to do whatever he was going to do -- no matter what popular opinion demanded. And I'm not holding my breath on this report either, despite the fact that Isikoff is a great reporter with sources at the highest levels.

If this story does pan out, and the President doesn't pardon Scooter Libby or Ted Stevens -- or preemptively pardon his administration -- it seems to me that the scandal surrounding Rod Blagojevich will have played a not insignificant role. With the alleged sale of a Senate seat being thoroughly discussed throughout the press in recent weeks, could a President, even George W. Bush, really escape unscathed from pardoning or commuting the sentences of those in his administration and party? While President Bush (and I am happy to say this is the last time I will be using those two words in succession without the modifier "former" attached) may not care about his current approval numbers, he does seem to worry about the way he is viewed by history, and excusing the official misconduct of cronies might be an unpardonable sin for Americans, in the long run as well as in the short.

Tags: bush administration, George W. Bush, pardons, Scooter Libby (all tags)

Comments

6 Comments

Bush's statement when he commuted

Libby's sentence really didn't leave him much wiggle room on this.  Occam's Razor suggests Bush made up his mind not to grant a pardon after the sentencing.

by Geekesque 2009-01-19 12:53PM | 0 recs
Re: Isikoff: Bush Won't Pardon Libby, Stevens

I would not be surprised, in fact this would mean that one of my predictions came true for once.  Bush is super-concerned about his legacy of late, and I'd imagine one of the last things he wants to muddy it with would be some "Clintonesque" pardon.

by Steve M 2009-01-19 01:03PM | 0 recs
Steve M: Right for the Wrong Reason

Bush is concerned about his legacy and that is why he dare not pardon any of his inside colleagues.  A pardon lifts the Fifth Amendment bar against self-incrimination.  That bar protects Bush as much as it protects Rumsfeld, Gonzalez, and others.  To pardon them would open those pardoned to subpoenas from Congress and, one can hope, special prosecutors, where they would have to testify truthfully to avoid perjury.

Bush only cares about himself.  That is why there will be no high level pardons.

by Arthurkc 2009-01-19 04:50PM | 0 recs
Re: Isikoff: Bush Won't Pardon Libby, Stevens

Just the expression Former President Bush would have been enough, but his legacy should be full of criminal investigations of his and Cheney's actions.

by Jeter 2009-01-19 01:25PM | 0 recs
Re: Isikoff: Bush Won't Pardon Libby, Stevens

Here's my question: does this in any way redeem the soon to be former president?  To me, this news is actually kind of big deal, as I totally expected him to play politics and pardon everyone (except maybe the blanket torture pardon because he really doesn't believe it was wrong).  Does he get a brownie point or not?

by viperlmw 2009-01-19 02:47PM | 0 recs
Re: Isikoff: Bush Won't Pardon Libby, Stevens

Good solid speech. I think he wanted to start his Presidency off with his take on our collective reality and how we must go forward to make it better. Realism is a welcome habit after 8 yrs. of wishful thinking and Corp. rah rah. The BV$H Presidency was marked by this arrogant notion that whatever reality "they" decided on was reality then as I remember the rest of us would then watch as "they" changed history and we would then study it. Well, it didn't quite work out that way did it? Obama is saying the opposite as I see it. Here's reality and let's all deal with it. Good starting pt.

by Blutodog 2009-01-20 11:28AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------