Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back the clock on abortion

Ben Smith reported yesterday at Politico that Barack Obama's campaign is running radio ads in at least seven states about John McCain's stand on abortion.

I heard this ad in the car yesterday and this morning on two Des Moines-area radio stations: the oldies station KIOA and LITE 104.1. LITE heavily skews toward female listeners. I don't know about the gender breakdown of KIOA listeners, but that station generally appeals to an older audience, many of whom would remember when abortion was illegal.

Smith published the script:

   OBAMA: I'm Barack Obama, candidate for president, and I approved this message.

   VAL BARON: As a nurse practitioner with Planned Parenthood, I know abortion is one of the most difficult decisions a woman will ever make. I'm Val Baron. Let me tell you: If Roe v Wade is overturned, the lives and health of women will be put at risk.  That's why this election is so important.  John McCain's out of touch with women today. McCain wants to take away our right to choose. That's what women need to understand. That's how high the stakes are.

   ANNCR: As president, John McCain will make abortion illegal.  McCain says quote, "I do not support Roe v. Wade. It should be overturned." And listen to McCain's answer on Meet the Press:

       RUSSERT: "A constitutional amendment to ban all abortions. You're for that?"
        McCAIN: "Yes, sir."

   VAL BARON: We can't let John McCain take away our right to choose. We can't let him take us back.

   ANNCR: Paid for by Obama for America.

Yesterday I heard a shorter version of this ad, which is identical except that it does not have the Planned Parenthood nurse practitioner speaking at the beginning. Today I have only heard the longer version.

A few points worth noting about this ad:

It does not mention Sarah Palin or the fact that McCain picked an anti-choice running mate. The entire focus is on McCain's record on abortion. Smith reports the ad was cut before McCain selected Palin, and I think it's wise they did not revise to include anything about her. Keep the focus on McCain, who is not at all moderate on this issue.

Including the undated audio clip with Russert and McCain is effective, in my opinion. That is more memorable than anything a voice-over could say about McCain's position on abortion.

I prefer the long version of the ad, because I think it's powerful to have a nurse say abortion is a difficult decision for women. The anti-choice forces try to make it sound as if pro-choice people celebrate or even encourage "abortion on demand." However, most Americans understand that whatever their own views about the issue, abortion is not something women take lightly. Complicated personal circumstances lead to the decision.

These ads mark a major shift in strategy for the Obama campaign. Up to now, the campaign has been emphasizing economic issues rather than abortion at its women's outreach events. Click the link to read about the Obama women's event I attended a few weeks ago, during which Roe v Wade was only mentioned in passing.

Although Democratic candidates have not often made abortion the focus of paid advertising, I think this is a smart ad. Way too many women wrongly believe McCain is pro-choice. Even my stepmother, who is well-informed politically, thought that.

Now that McCain has played his hand and picked a running mate who appeals to evangelicals seeking to overturn Roe v. Wade, it's the right time to educate pro-choice women about McCain's true record on the issue.

The potential downside is that these ads will increase McCain's support among anti-choice voters. Although McCain scores zero on Progressive Punch's rankings on abortion as well as a perfectly anti-choice zero on Planned Parenthood's scorecard, many evangelical conservatives believe McCain does not have a pro-life voting record.

Incredibly, some figures on the Christian right believe McCain has a pro-abortion voting record (see here for more details on that perspective).

This ad makes crystal clear that McCain would try to make abortion illegal if elected president.

On the other hand, McCain has presumably already energized anti-choice voters by selecting Palin for vice-president. Also, I have yet to see any poll showing that a majority of Americans would like to see abortion criminalized.

Please put up a comment if you have heard these ads, with details about when and what kind of radio station aired them.

UPDATE: A Bleeding Heartland user saw Cindy McCain tell Katie Couric on CBS News tonight that she supports Roe v Wade. This echoes the tactic they used in previous elections, when it was made known that Laura Bush also would not like Roe v Wade to be overturned. We cannot allow this deception to give pro-choice voters a false sense of security. No matter what Laura Bush thinks, George W. Bush to my knowledge has not appointed any judges who support Roe v Wade.

Tags: 2008 elections, abortion, Barack Obama, John McCain, Planned Parenthood (all tags)

Comments

19 Comments

Great ad, and I think there is NO downside for us

"The potential downside is that these ads will increase McCain's support among anti-choice voters. Although McCain scores zero on Progressive Punch's rankings on abortion as well as a perfectly anti-choice zero on Planned Parenthood's scorecard, many evangelical conservatives believe McCain does not have a pro-life voting record."

That may have mattered before the Palin pick, now every pro-life group has been notified and received it's marching orders.

I think this is a problem not for Obama, but for Palin and the McCain campaign.

The pro-life movement would like her to be the Poster-woman for Pro-choice, but, as you said, I think Rick Davis would like to keep that flying under that radar.

They HAVE the Pro-choice Dobson vote onboard now.

It's now up to us to make sure every mother, ever father of a daugther knows where these people stand.

This is NOT just a woman's issue.

It is about my daughter and her daughter (if and when she shows up....)

by WashStateBlue 2008-09-03 03:58PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back the clo

I heard it twice today on KWY 1060 News in Philly

It's a great ad, I'd venture to say the hardest hitting ad from Obama thus far.

by dannybauder 2008-09-03 04:17PM | 0 recs
Heard in Washington

This morning.  I was in the dentist's office, so I don't know what station it was on.

by BRoss 2008-09-03 04:24PM | 0 recs
The anti-choice base

will already be motivated to vote for McCain on the hope that God strike him down and allows Sarah "I want to force my daughters to have their rapists' babies" Palin to appoint Supreme Court justices.

The major point of this is to bring home the more independent pro-choice voters who might not trust Obama but think McCain is acceptable.

The objective here is to make McCain unacceptable and confront the misconceptions about his record on choice head-on.  I applaud it wholeheartedly.

by hekebolos 2008-09-03 04:25PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back the clo

I haven't heard the ad, but you can't go wrong with firing up our base. Our biggest strength going into this election is Democratic enthusiasm. Maintaining or even expanding that is just as important as winning over independents.

by Covin 2008-09-03 04:25PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

I'm trying to avoid as much of the GOP convention as possible, but can someone who's been watching please tell me if I'm wrong in noticing that the Rethugs seem be picking a fight with the media rather than Obama?

If so, keep it up!

by ObamaBiden 2008-09-03 04:28PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

Yup. They're going to talk about the Washington east-coast elite.

MITT ROMNEY is going to talk about the East coast elite, an irony not lost on Keith Olbermann (or Chris Matthews, can't remember who).

It's insane. They are betting the farm that Palin turns the polls completely around and makes everyone in the press forced to play ball. I don't think that will be as easy as they think it will be. Their position isn't as strong with independents as they think it is.

by vcalzone 2008-09-03 04:33PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

Oh, but don't worry. Palin hasn't been swayed by Obama's refusal to speak ill of her. She's still going to attack his character. Why? Because she's classy.

by vcalzone 2008-09-03 04:34PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

All I saw was Tom Brokaw mocking them with derision.

But if they don't want to campaign against Obama that's fine by me. It's like punching at the referee with the other fighter punches them.

by ObamaBiden 2008-09-03 04:47PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

That was rich coming form Romney, he of the $250 million fortune, the son of a governor, alum of The Cranbrook School in depressed Bloomfield Hills, admitted to Stanford, and graduate of Harvard Business School.

It takes a man of the people to recognize another in John "Seven Homes" McCain.

by Trond Jacobsen 2008-09-03 05:36PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back

It's nice to see a candidate who isn't afraid to turn the wedge issues back against the Republicans.  Contrary to what many think, the country is very supportive of keeping abortion legal.

by Skaje 2008-09-03 04:39PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back

He also should attack Palin and McCain's position on birth control. Many Catholic voters are against abortion, but some 80% of American Catholics are pro-contraception, contrary to the Church's teaching.  Not everyone wants a litter like Palin. Let them think about not being able to get condoms or the Pill.

by antiHyde 2008-09-03 05:01PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads:

Great post, DesmoinesDem.

I'm glad he's doing this.  McCain's moderate image is dissolving in the spotlight put upon his real stands.  And palin just reinforces it.

by TomP 2008-09-03 04:45PM | 0 recs
Re: Obama radio ads: McCain will turn back the clo

Nice scare tactic to frighten women.
2/3 of the states will have to approve such an amendment.  You can't even get an Equal Rights Amendment passed, don't worry about Roe-v Wade.

People "say" they are against abortion, but in private they think different.

by stefystef 2008-09-03 05:19PM | 0 recs
at least 20 states

have already approved abortion bans that would go into effect immediately if the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade.

Banning abortion would not require a constitutional amendment in these states.

by desmoinesdem 2008-09-03 05:29PM | 0 recs
Re: at least 20 states

I know there are states looking to overturn Roe v Wade.  This has been the case since Roe v Wade has been passed.

There's always a threat to Roe v Wade.  If you really want to ensure the rights, work on a Constitutional Amendment instead.  And control who McCain puts in the Supreme Court.  Tell the Congress to do their damn job.

Nobody puts Pelosi's feet to the fire... it's time people did.

by stefystef 2008-09-03 06:24PM | 0 recs
Off topic question DMD

But are you surprised that Palin hasn't made an impact in Iowa if we believe the poll that CNN released today?  I actually thought that Iowa was one of the states where Palin would help McCain get closer, though even with Palin, I never thought he could make up a seven point disadvantage on average).  You would think Palin would help McCain pull away from Obama in Montana and North Carolina and put the nail in the coffin in Missouri but I'll wait for poll numbers to either confirm or disaffirm this hypothesis.

McCain probably sacrificed what little chance he had in MN but he may have turned a much larger hanging fruit, the state of Florida, into a total toss-up with his VP selection.  

by Blazers Edge 2008-09-03 05:34PM | 0 recs
Iowans like Joe Biden

Also, Iowans elected pro-choice Chet Culver in 2006 by a margin of about 100,000 votes. Since then the Democratic voter registration advantage in Iowa has increased substantially.

So no, I'm not surprised that Palin has not improved McCain's standing in Iowa.

Remove Iowa from your swing-state column. I'll eat my hat if McCain beats Obama here.

by desmoinesdem 2008-09-03 06:00PM | 0 recs
Stupid, stupid idea

He's not going to pick up any new voters with that one and he'll sure send a lot away.

DO NOT RUN ON WEDGE ISSUES.

Its too late in the election season to play around with these ridiculous experiments.  They're not working, just as Obama has no doubt been told they wont.

Voters don't want to hear about getting an abortion, they want to hear about how we're going to prevent a meltdown in our economy.  Why can't Obama talk about jobs and health care?  Why is he acting like such a moron?

by Betsy McCall 2008-09-08 04:51AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------