Free Advice
by Jerome Armstrong, Sat Sep 13, 2008 at 07:35:11 AM EDT
There's a free advice column of commentary on Obama's campaign, from Dukakis, Trippi, Myers, Rendell and Cuban. Here's some excerpts:
Dukakis:
I read this over and over, but where's the proof for this assumption? People seem to have extrapolated that Obama did phenomenal job of organizing in caucus states in the primary, to a GE, and skipped over all the large states that he lost to Clinton. Pennsylvania, for example. Clinton won by 55-45, the same margin by which she led when the six week campaign began. Plus, Dukakis is so out-of-touch if he can't see what Palin has done for McCain in regards to their base. And Ahem. And besides, the last time I read Dukakis complaining about Obama, it was that Obama wasn't organizing enough.
I don't see an advantage in organizing for Obama against McCain, especially given there are no 527's helping out this time (yes, that is a double-edged sword). Yes, Obama has more people working in more states, but alot of those, like the ones in GA, AK, MT, FL, NC, IN, are not going to matter to the final outcome. It's only in a state like Ohio, where there's a window for early voting, that Obama might gain some extra votes through organizing. Lets see it happen Sept. 30 through Oct. 6 in Ohio. But the Republicans proved in '04 that they can organize just as well as Democrats, and there's no reason to assume they forgot, especially given that McCain has adopted the entire Bush campaign infrastructure.
Trippi:
The McCain campaign seems to have figured out, by watching Clinton, that saying he has been in Washington for 26 years and has more experience isn't going to work. So, what did they do? They picked Palin specifically so he could move the focus and the decision point in the race. It's no longer experience versus change; it's reform and change versus change. Now it's up to the Obama people to adjust.
This is painful, but probably correct. I view it a bit differently. The election has been painted with a broad stroke as one of experience vs change, and both candidates adjusted with their VP picks. That leaves Democrats with change at the top of the ticket and experience with the VP, and Republicans with the exact opposite ticket. That's why arguing that Palin is not experienced is so ineffectual-- it undermines Obama.
On the broader point, 'reform' is the only way that Republicans can brand themselves and win in '08. Right now, Obama is not targeting that at all, instead battling over 'change' while McCain is busily defining what change is-- reform. Look at what Jeb Bush thinks reform means to see the way to define it against them. Lobbyist reform? What a waste of time to the average voter.
Myers:
Sadly true. That was probably the most idiotic exploitation and evaporation of credibility I've ever witnessed. To no effect against Palin or McCain.
Myers:
Cuban:
The interesting thing about Ron Paul's internet and real world efforts is that they haven't been negative. They have been positive feedback about their candidate rather than negative about the opposition.
If Obama can "Ron Paul" McCain before McCain does it to him, he could see a change.
I talked with a GOP operative that mentioned to me that, not only was McCain doing weekly outreach to the political bloggers, with weekly conference calls, but that they'd segmented down to all of the other blogosphere's too, entertainment, sports, food, tech... found the Republicans, and are doing weekly calls with them as well. That's online organizing for message coordination; that's how you possibly avoid the type of decentralized out-of-control message disaster that happened with the personal attacks against Palin.
Rendell:
I think the environment, the political landscape, has radically changed in the past two weeks. I see it at the statewide level, in the races I'm working. There seems to have been a 'run out the clock' mentality among the Democrats going into the homestretch. It'd be ill-advised to not adjust. I'm sure that Obama's campaign will adjust, but lets not pretend that this is a situation that they expected themselves to be, especially given where they were a mere couple of months ago.















126 Comments