Rothenberg: Democrats Favored in At Least 4 GOP-Held Districts

The folks over at The Rothenberg Political Report are out with its latest House race ratings, and the numbers look awfully good for the Democrats.

Going through the list overall, 40 Republican-held districts are listed as being vulnerable at this point, as compared with just 23 for the Democrats. Even more problematic for the GOP than the overall numbers are those districts most likely to flip -- those ranked toss-up/tilt retention, tossup, tossup/tilt loss, and leans loss. Among this group, there are 19 Republican districts and just nine for the Democrats. Even within this group for the Democrats, I'd question some of the placements -- for instance, it's hard for me to see Oregon's fifth, which is being vacated by Democratic Rep. Darlene Hooley and which has a Cook PVI of D+1, as being a tossup at this juncture, particularly considering that the more likely GOP nominee, Kevin Mannix, has lost four statewide races since 1996 (two for Attorney General and two for Governor) and is generally widely unpopular while the more likely Democratic nominee, state Sen. Kurt Schrader, has a proven track record of winning elections in the district and has the ability to self-fund, to a degree; Kansas 2, where Democrat Nancy Boyda is running for a second term, features a very bitter and potentially divisive GOP primary, which should make it fairly difficult for the party to pick up the seat.

Perhaps even more importantly, Rothenberg rates four races in districts currently held by the GOP as tossup/tilts Democratic (1) or leans Democratic (3), and just one race in a district currently held by the Democrats as tossup/tilts Republican. Specifically, Rothenberg gives the Democrats a slight advantage to pick up the seat left open by Jim Saxon in New Jersey, and gives the Democrats a slightly greater advantage to pick up the seats left open by Jerry Weller in Illinois, Jim Walsh in New York and Tom Davis in Virginia. The only district in which Rothenberg sees the Republicans as having a better than even shot at picking up a seat is Texas 22nd district, where Nick Lampson is running for reelection.

I'm not going to run down the whole list of races -- you can read them over at Rothenberg's blog. But suffice it to say that Rothenberg is on to something: The Democrats have a much better shot at picking up seats and are less vulnerable to losing seats than are the Republicans, a reality that will make it darn near impossible for the GOP to retake its majority in the House in 2008.

Tags: House 2008 (all tags)

Comments

6 Comments

Re: Rothenberg:

These are the shifts we started seeing in mid-2006, first it was a couple tossup GOP seats, then several, then one or two actually leaning Dem, and by election day we had a dozen takeovers more or less in the bag, with opportunities at dozens more.

We netted 30, a feat which looks to repeat itself this year in the House.

A good working majority for either Obama or Clinton to get legislation passed.

by Skaje 2008-04-18 01:22PM | 0 recs
Gerry Connolly will take Tom Davis's seat

You heard it here first...

Despite ActBlue endorsing Leslie Byrne - a fine person, but middling politician - Connolly will win the endorsement and the election in comfortable fashion...

And that's a good thing...he'll do a good job!

by SaveElmer 2008-04-18 01:36PM | 0 recs
Re: Rothenberg: Democrats Favored in At Least 4 GO
AK's Young listed as toss-up leans Rep...
Given his legal troubles this might not last...
by nogo war 2008-04-18 02:05PM | 0 recs
It leans republican but

I doubt the Alaskans have much respect for the corruption in the Republican party.  They're pretty independent types up there.  We might not get a Dem in but an Indie could have a shot at it for sure.

by GFORD 2008-04-18 05:52PM | 0 recs
Re: Rothenberg: Democrats Favored in At Least 4 GO

With Jim Saxton retiring the NJ-3 is prime for a Democratic takeover. Senator John Adler is raising massive amounts of money to fund a competitive race against two second tier Republican candidates (Over $1 million CoH). CQ noted the Adler campaign as number 10 in the country in terms of increasing their Cash on Hand.

http://www.bluejersey.com/showDiary.do;j sessionid=7D0F117FB1CF2EF5729840538974A2 37?diaryId=7537

Adler is on the DCCC Red to Blue program, and has received endorsements from The Sierra Club and the Recreational Fishing Alliance. I urge all MyDDers to continue to keep tabs on this important race in NJ.

by MAS117 2008-04-18 11:09PM | 0 recs
Re: Rothenberg: Democrats Favored ...

"Kansas 2, where Democrat Nancy Boyda is running for a second term, features a very bitter and potentially divisive GOP primary, which should make it fairly difficult for the party to pick up the seat."

Maybe, but I'm not shocked that Boyda's race is rated "Pure Toss-Up."  This is her first re-elect and it's not like she didn't hit a couple of bumps in her first term.

The surprising listing is the Kansas 3rd, Dennis Moore's race, which is only listed "Lean Democratic."  Unless Moore does something akin to making a video where he high-fives Osama bin Laden, he's going to get re-elected.

by Shocker Jim 2008-04-19 12:41AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------