Should the President Really Be Reading Two Books a Week?

Karl Rove, on his book reading competition against President Bush in 2006.

At year's end, I defeated the president, 110 books to 95. My trophy looks suspiciously like those given out at junior bowling finals. The president lamely insisted he'd lost because he'd been busy as Leader of the Free World.

I'm not certain that I want my President to be reading nearly two books a week. This isn't to say, of course, that I don't believe a President should be well read, or that the President shouldn't be allowed to have down time to do things that can, even for a short time, take his mind off the nearly unfathomably grave issues he must confront on a daily basis.

But just thinking about these numbers -- 1.83 books per week -- you get the sense that the President could more efficiently use his time. Just going by the amount of reading I do on a day-to-day basis between reading for blogging and reading for law school, it's difficult for me to get through more than a dozen books a year, give or take a few -- and only then generally during real breaks (which presumably a President doesn't get much of). I would assume that the job of the President of the United States requires as much or more reading than does the job of being a political blogging law student, or at least as much or more active attention, so it's difficult for me to visualize where the time to read a couple books (whether it's James L. Swanson's "Manhunt" or Albert Camus's "The Stranger") every single week would materialize for a President.

Update [2008-12-27 13:11:40 by Jonathan Singer]:Ezra Klein on point:

No one cares if Bush has read an Andrew Jackson biography. It's his unfamiliarity with his briefing books, not with Founding Fathers porn, that most concerned the nation.

Tags: George W. Bush (all tags)

Comments

38 Comments

Two books a week

I guess it depends on the President... and the book.

Did reading My Pet Goat twice in a week count for one book or two?

(From what I've heard, President-Elect Obama is a voracious reader.  Being something of a quick reader myself, where I can go through three or four books in a week even apart from my grad school reading, I wouldn't be surprised if he could knock off two a week.)

by mistersite 2008-12-26 01:26PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Two books a week

I was about to ask the same question.   I am sure W can knock of the Pokey Little Puppy in under 30 minutes.  Green Eggs and Ham may take a little longer.

I would rather have my President reading books rather than watching TV.

by gavoter 2008-12-26 02:50PM | login to reply | 0 recs
My Pet Goat was actually

part of the President's regular Great Books of the Western World discussion group.  The look of shock on the President's face was because one of the 3rd graders on the panel had just challenged the President's supposition that the goat represented an anti-hero.

by pascal1947 2008-12-26 03:57PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo
I differ with you...2 books aweek is fine ...even more.  the president  Iat least the upcoming one) is not reading Zane Grey...he's reading books about the ideas his job addresses.  Books are ideas writ large, books that require thinking are a good way to burst the bubble of 1600 Penn Ave.  
First they take his blackberry and now you want his library? Palli
by palli 2008-12-26 01:50PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

Preznit B can read?  Wow?  I thought the Pet Goat book was a stretch for him.  Well, he'll have plenty of time to contemplate his navel and read comics and stuff!!   Certainly all  Mr Evil would be into would be Art Of War or Machiavelli.  No?

by docpatmac1 2008-12-26 02:30PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Reading Two Books

Were they "Chapter" books?

by qtg 2008-12-26 02:35PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Reading Two Books

Probably comic books.

by antihyde 2008-12-26 02:58PM | login to reply | 0 recs
I don't buy it

This defies credibility. I don't for a moment believe that Bush reads. I don't think he even watches the news. He lacks any and all curiosity.

by charles lemos 2008-12-26 02:39PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

If Bush was reading 1.8 books a week, then I want a President who reads 20, not fucking ZERO.

How on earth anyone could hold the opinion that the President of the United States SHOULD NOT READ is un-fucking-believable.

A List of Obvious Red Flags:

  • Bad example to children?
  • Cutting of a source of new perspective?
  • Source of mental exercise?
  • Source of new ideas?
  • Expanding one's cultural perspective?
  • Example to the rest of the world?
  • The President is a human being who's job is leader of this country and just because he's got that job doesn't mean he should sacrifice everything about his personal life because that is completely unreasonable to expect of anyone?

Just because an idiot hasn't turned his reading into anything resembling positive change doesn't mean reading is the problem. An idiot is an idiot.

I'm really, really disappointed with this post.

by jmendonsa 2008-12-26 03:01PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

You're entirely missing the point of the post, and misquoting me as saying the President should not be reading (where in fact I say the exact opposite). The point is not that the President should not read, it's that the President is doing something wrong if he has that much free time on his hands.

The Presidency is not a 9 to 5 job -- or even a 7 to 5 job, which is how George W. Bush reportedly treats it. It is a job that can require a President to devote nearly all waking hours (indeed, Bill Clinton often worked until 2 or 3 in the morning to get the job done).

Again, to reiterate what I wrote in the post, a President should most certainly be afforded down time -- a human could not survive a job like the Presidency without relaxation. But at the same time, a President shouldn't have so much free time so that he is remiss in his duties, and from the looks of the last eight years we have had a Chief Executive who has at times been remiss in his duties.

by jonathan singer 2008-12-26 06:04PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

Don't worry, John.

The story of him reading that many books is a lie anyway--just another Rove image-building exercise.

Have you ever heard him speak knowledgeably of any of the subjects he alledgedly read about? Have you ever seen him carrying a book on and off the plane?

More than likely, he was spending his time riding his bike or on another of his many mindless vacations.

by bush bites 2008-12-27 06:46AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: President Really Read Two Books a Week?

I want to see the list and exactly how many times "My Pet Goat" is listed... then a Bush written book report on each book.

by suznaz 2008-12-26 03:29PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: President Reading Two Books a Week?

I'm with jmendonsa on this.  This is a really disappointing post.  Nobody, and I repeat nobody, should be encouraged not to read.  I'd suggest it's you that needs to find more time to read, not the president reading less.

by cjlacz 2008-12-26 03:45PM | login to reply | 0 recs
What should a President Be Reading?

That's the better question.  

It really does matter whether it's Zane Grey or Walter Isaacson.

Shrub certainly doesn't speak or act like an individual who is well read in history, government, economics, foreign affairs or science.

First year law school demands a huge amount of time reading case books.  Once you pass the bar, you'll find that your capacity has enlarged to the point that 2000 pages per week of non-work related reading, not including the daily papers, will seem a relaxed pace.

by martinlomasney 2008-12-26 04:04PM | login to reply | 0 recs
A silly post

Now what do you say next year if it comes out that Obama has been reading 3 books per week?

It all depends on the book.  Some books are a breeze to read in a day or two.  Others require weeks, or even months if we're talking about a dense Russian novelist.  

Ivy league students, which Bush once was, are generally expected to read 2+ books per week per class.

A better question is: what is Bush reading?  

by rickd 2008-12-26 04:35PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: A silly post

"Ivy league students, which Bush once was, are generally expected to read 2+ books per week per class."

1) Bush has a day job.  It requires a shit ton of reading.  

2) No, they aren't.

by ab03 2008-12-26 08:29PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: A silly post

By all accounts, he didn't even read his morning briefings, he took them orally from a briefer.

This "Bush Reads XXX Books" is as phony as his ranch and the story of Billy Graham introducing him to Jesus.

It's all part of the Rove image and legacy building.

by bush bites 2008-12-27 06:43AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: A silly post

I can verify that Ivy League students are not expected to read 2 books per week, per class.  That's pretty far off the mark from my experience.

by rfahey22 2008-12-27 04:15PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two

I confess I missed the part of this post where it was suggested that the President shouldn't be reading at all.  I'm sure I'd be just as outraged as the others who saw that passage, but I just can't seem to locate it.

by steve m 2008-12-26 05:03PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two

Thanks.

by jonathan singer 2008-12-26 06:05PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

What would the perfect number be?  If he had read 56 books, would you have said "darn, he nailed it"?

I forget which conservative smacked Maher down with that when he raised it on Real Time a couple of years back.  I was surprised the guy had such wit.

Seriously, this is such a non-issue.  Bush read some--not a sin, but a virtue.

by sean fitzpatrick 2008-12-26 05:35PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Should the President Really Be Reading Two Books

Typical Rove...if you're going to tell a lie make it a whopper.  My guess is that neither one of them read a single book all the way through last year.

Rove is too hyper and spends his time reading newspapers, polls, etc.  Bush is too dumb, spends his time trying to amuse others in the White House.

by gford 2008-12-26 07:03PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

How's he amusing people if he's a mute, learn the meaning of the word...dumb

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:19PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Bush actually read 40 books this year

95 was in 2006.

Anyway, I do think it is kind of amazing that he reads like that.  The only thing I can think of is that he reads really quickly.  Maybe I'm naive in assuming that he did actually read the books or that he is actually spending a decent amount of time at the Presidency.

But it does make it difficult to believe that he was reading that quickly.  He had to have been skimming/speed reading where he's only moderately comprehending.  There just isn't enough time to yourself as a President to get through that many books.  

by ab03 2008-12-26 08:32PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Bush actually read 40 books this year

"Maybe I'm naive in assuming that he did actually read the books..."

BINGO!

by bush bites 2008-12-27 06:39AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Bush actually read 40 books this year

Or...he's smart, maybe reread some books thats faster.  Or he's smart and can read a 100 pages in 30 min-1 hour.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:18PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Meh.

I don't believe anything Rove says anyway.

by fogiv 2008-12-26 09:52PM | login to reply | 0 recs
aaaaa

Exactly. This is extremely disturbing if true--the presdiency is not a typical job affording loads of free time to read 2 books a week!

It speaks to Bush's laziness and lack of interest in the job (probably delegating the majority of his authority to the real president Cheney) that he had time to read 100 books in a year.

by need some wood 2008-12-27 12:27AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: aaaaa

So increasing his intellect so he's a better individual isn't being a good president.  Whats he suppose to be doing checking up on every nut that says a UFO just landed to see if it pans out. And think about all the time he has before bed and traveling, or how much he has to know about foreign cultures he's probably read half of his books on topics like that and only a few for pleasure.  Maybe he's read some Presidential Memoirs or political analysis "The Prince" for example.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:17PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Busy Bush

"The president lamely insisted he'd lost because he'd been busy as Leader of the Free World."

Not that busy.  He has been on vacation or travelling to it fully one third of his time as President.

by bob h 2008-12-27 01:26AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Busy Bush

Bush has never taken a vacation other than to the Fort.  Everywhere else was for foreign policy he doesn't want people to worry so much.  And even at the Fort he's checking up on a lot of lower republican conservatives or military types-the day he takes a break will be when he transfers the office over.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:13PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

>But just thinking about these numbers -- 1.83 books per week -- you get the sense that the President could more efficiently use his time.

I get the sense that you shouldn't be so desperate to attack Mr Bush.

Perhaps - like a lot of people - he reads in bed.

Anyway - the tells us more about Jonathon Singer than it does about G Bush.

File under Lame.

by mw2000 2008-12-27 05:12AM | login to reply | 0 recs
I never believed that.

Bush?

C'mon. He's never spoken knowledgeably of any of the books he alledgedly read.

That's just all part of the image building stuff, same as the phony ranch and the phony story of him being converted by Billy Graham and all the rest.

by bush bites 2008-12-27 06:36AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: I never believed that.

Your post brought up the idea in my head that he hasn't really ever spoken knowledgeably period.  Wouldn't a strong grasp on the English language be required to read that much?

by selfevident 2008-12-27 11:46AM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: I never believed that.

Yeah and Obama is real brilliant, where'd he goto college.  Not that I hate Obama or support Bush or McCain I simply see them all as about a 5, a 4, and a 6 on the presidential scale.  We need more leaders like Washington and Jefferson.  And on a sidenote anyone who claims Nixon almost made this a dictatorship actually the two who came closest and were most likely to A. Lincoln and F.Roosevelt learn your history.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:10PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading

I don't believe it, but that does cause some concern in my mind, if true.  I sort of envision a President as working from the time s/he awakes until the time s/he goes to sleep, though clearly Bush would not fit that image.

by rfahey22 2008-12-27 04:20PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading

The president doesn't have that much power, and his power has increased a lot in the past 75 years since FDR.  In general the Federal government's power has.  Stop asking the government to solve all your problems. I bet you are one of the people who think its wrong that Bush was reading to children on 9-11.  He finished reading, how great of character is that.  You don't abandon children, or your commitments and you certainly shouldn't frighten them.  I don't love Bush but realistically he wasn't that bad, he just came at a bad time and place and perhaps had the most corrupt cabinet since JFK or Nixons time.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:06PM | login to reply | 0 recs
Re: Should the President Really Be Reading Two Boo

Your post I found interesting.  The comments however very foolish, George W. Bush is smarter than a good 90 percent of people. I am actually willing to go higher but i mean intelligence as in the ability to learn and understand, so simply within the U.S our average citizen's intelligence is high but adding in the new "Y" generation they're intelligence would throw everything off. Escaping this tangent Bush is most likely reading very insightful books and many for pleasure, I'd guess ones he chooses are greatly related to sports-he's a real man's man.  But I am so sick of the Bush is an idiot joke, I once thought he was an idiotic puppet now I'm not going to write an essay on this but from what I hear his lowest grades ever were C's for a top prep school and ivy leaguer who seems like a bit of a slacker thats pretty good. Some of the most brilliant people simply aren't great public speaker's, I suppose now Nixon wasn't the smartest President-Gimme a break.

by tc6125 2009-01-04 11:02PM | login to reply | 0 recs

Login

 

Sign-in-with-twitter-lighter

Advertise Blogads