McCain's Latest Attack: Obama "The Redistributor"

First they jumped on Barack Obama for telling "Joe" the "plumber" that he wants to "spread the wealth around" and now they've unearthed a 7 year old radio interview in which Barack Obama talks about "redistributive change" (transcript is HERE.) It must be pretty important because Drudge has it as his big headlilne of the day and it's led the McCain campaign to break out yet another ridiculous attack on Barack Obama:

At a rally with a few thousand people outside of Dayton, Sen. John McCain slammed his Democratic rival for a 2001 radio interview in which Obama discussed the political science concept of "redistributive change."

"That is what change means for Obama administration -- the Redistributor," McCain said. "It means taking your money and giving it to someone else. He believes in redistributing wealth, not in policies that grow our economy and create jobs."

First of all, let the record show that on This Week yesterday none other than George Will, Cokie Roberts and Peggy Noonan explained the ridiculousness of running against redistributive wealth as a concept, particularly in 2008:

Will: 95% of what the government does is redistribute wealth...

Roberts: And the tax code is filled with redistributive principles.

Noonan: I don't think that what Mrs. Palin was saying there in regard to socialism, etc. is going to get a big response from 8 million new registered voters this cycle many of whom are very young...18, 19, 20...I don't think after the last 7 years it's going to work.

Not to mention that, as Ann Althouse makes clear -- again, no liberal she -- the position Obama is taking in that radio interview is at most "a moderate view of law."

But look at the longer view of what the McCain campaign is doing here by making the election a battle of ideologies. As Marc Ambinder rightly points out:

Whether or not the Frums of the punditosphere are correct, it might be dangerous for the Republican Party to elevate the stakes for this election to a death match between competing ideologies. If Barack Obama's victory is as decisive as it is shaping up to be, the Democrats can justifiably claim that conservatism itself has been rejected as a political and governing philosophy. In the closing weeks of the campaign, as the Republican ticket continues to run against the very idea of progressive politics, they are sowing the seeds of the post-election realignment narrative.

David Sirota made the same point the other day.

We're living through the first election in modern history that is about whether to vote for free market fundamentalism, or vote for a change from that fundamentalism. That choice has not been the creation of Obama, but of the Republicans. And should America vote against free market fundamentalism on election day, the GOP will have helped craft a mandate for a progressive economic era.

The conservative movement folks still believe, you see, that America is, at its core, a conservative nation, so they truly think that if the fight is on this turf, they will win handily. What they don't seem to get is how spectacularly this could backfire on them and on the future of conservatism (unless that's already an oxymoron.) This is one attack on Obama that we should all welcome.

Tags: Barack Obama, John McCain, redistributive change (all tags)

Comments

15 Comments

Re: McCain

 Grampy needs a nap.

by QTG 2008-10-27 05:28PM | 0 recs
Just Remember

35% top federal tax rate?
Capitalist!  Free marketeer!  Supporter of entreprenuers!

39.6% top federal tax rate?
Socialist!  Wealth spreader!  Admirer of Karl Marx!

Helluva difference 4.6% makes, huh?

by Collideascope 2008-10-27 05:35PM | 0 recs
Re: Just Remember

You've been reading Hendrik Hertzberg:


The Republican argument of the moment seems to be that the difference between capitalism and socialism corresponds to the difference between a top marginal income-tax rate of 35 per cent and a top marginal income-tax rate of 39.6 per cent. The latter is what it would be under Obama's proposal, what it was under President Clinton, and, for that matter, what it will be after 2010 if President Bush's tax cuts expire on schedule. Obama would use some of the added revenue to give a break to pretty much everybody who nets less than a quarter of a million dollars a year. The total tax burden on the private economy would be somewhat lighter than it is now--a bit of elementary Keynesianism that renders doubly untrue the Republican claim that Obama "will raise your taxes."

Hendrik Hertzberg - Like, Socialism New Yorker 3 Nov 08

The money quote - Perhaps there is some meaningful distinction between spreading the wealth and sharing it, but finding it would require the analytic skills of Karl the Marxist.  Sigh, such fun...

by Shaun Appleby 2008-10-27 05:58PM | 0 recs
Re: McCain's Latest Attack: Obama

People have no idea of what socialism is. No concept at all. By this definition any instance in which a tax code becomes more progressive is socialist.

They are really pushing this "Obama Is The Re-Distributor" thing. I don't think they ran that one past Frank Luntz. It hardly resonates with people's lives right now. "Re-Distributor" isn't the best buzz word I ever heard this close to an election.

Personally, I like the word "Corrupt" after the verdict against Ted Stevens today and the behavior of Republicans over the past 8 years.

"John McCain, Sarah Palin, part of a corrupt system, corrupt political party, and a corrupted political philosophy."

by Graham1979 2008-10-27 05:49PM | 0 recs
But...
If McCain wins, this will be the reason why.  
I hate to say it, but this could be the one issue that wins it for McCain.
by esconded 2008-10-27 06:03PM | 0 recs
Re: But...

Ha ha ha ha ha!

(Really, that was a good one.)

Yeah, THIS is going to put the nail in Obama's coffin.

by Hammer1001 2008-10-27 06:07PM | 0 recs
Re: But...

More likely the stake in conservatism's heart for a generation.

by Shaun Appleby 2008-10-27 06:14PM | 0 recs
Re: But...

I thought it was going to be because of William Ayers... that's what you said a couple of weeks ago....

by LordMike 2008-10-27 06:12PM | 0 recs
Re: But...

Give him a break, the guy is desperately searching for anything to base his deep, deep concern upon.  Maybe he'll even be able use this to dig out a sinking poll poll diary.  

by January 20 2008-10-27 07:47PM | 0 recs
Re: But...

I'm a pessimist too. But, I think we're going to be okay, as long as Obama doesn't let up this week on John McCain. They should be attacking him for saying he shares Bush's political philosophy . Look where that philosophy has got us.

Also I can't get my head around the Republican's arrogance. If our tax code gives more and more to the rich, producing no trickle down results at all, this is "patriotic" and in the spirit of this nation. But, a tax cut for the working and middle class... that's just Marxism and Socialism. It's so wrong I can't believe they are not getting hammered for it. All they are doing is fighting for people who are doing fine in this economy. Small businesses are dying right now because they have no customers. They are clueless on the right.

by Graham1979 2008-10-27 10:42PM | 0 recs
Such Fun

As we observe the unexpectedly dramatic and pyrotechnic demise of the Republican party, conservatism in general and the splintering of the coalition which has presided over the ideological Salem witch trials of the last twelve years of American political discourse it is fair enough to be entertained and, yea, joyously buoyed up by the discomforts and helpless frustrations of our adversaries.  But it is worth standing back a respectful distance from the conflagration as the debris will scatter some considerable distance, much of it still burning with respectable heat.  Sacrificial parades and tom-toms by torchlight later, I'm joyously expecting.

Still, not to be missed, like a demolition derby on a NASCAR budget with no quarter expected or given.  Sigh.  I'm just happy to be alive to see it and not intending to miss a moment.  Pass us a cold beer, wouldja'...

by Shaun Appleby 2008-10-27 06:12PM | 0 recs
Re: McCain's Latest Attack: Obama "

Oh noes, Barack Obama wants to return to the communist hell that was the 90's...BEWARRRRE...BEEEEWWWAAAARRREEE

I am growing to hate these pricks.  They bring willful ignorance to an art form, except they hate art.

by tired of dynasties 2008-10-27 07:18PM | 0 recs
"The Redistributor"

I tuned away from NPR today & stumbled upon Mark Levin in the mids of an hours-long orgasm.  He was in socialistic ecstasy.   I gave it about 10 minutes then had to scrub down for an hour.  

by January 20 2008-10-27 07:51PM | 0 recs
Re: McCain's Latest: "The Redistributor"

In four years they've gone from flip-flopper to redistributor?

It almost sounds like a bad NASCAR joke.

by Gary Kilbride 2008-10-27 11:33PM | 0 recs
Re: ...Obama "The Redistributor"

I thought they were always running agaist us on this.  Though normally left to Conservative talking heads and AM radio hosts.  I figure McCain's going to that well, as with most everything he does, in order to appeal to the Republican base.  

Not sure it's going to resonate with moderates.  It certainly wont' scare away Liberals.

by nintendofanboy 2008-10-28 12:17PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------