Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Both contenders to dethrone John Cornyn have launched videos to introduce themselves to voters online.

Here's Rick Noriega's:

And here's Mikal Watt's:

Oh wait, his isn't embeddable so I'll just have to post Roll Call political analyst Stu Rothenberg's take instead.

... the candidate you meet in July of the off-year is not always the same person you see again 15 months later. Candidates, and their campaigns, often improve with experience, and they start to look better if and when their opponents start to fade.

Texas Senate hopeful Mikal Watts is getting plenty of attention these days because he has committed to putting as much as $10 million behind his bid for the Democratic nomination (against state Rep. Rick Noriega, a favorite of some in the party's netroots) and his challenge to incumbent Sen. John Cornyn (R). I haven't yet met Watts, so I have little to judge him by except for his campaign bank account - currently standing at more than $4 million -- and his Web site.

His money obviously is impressive. But money rarely is enough. If it were the only thing that mattered, Michael Huffington (R) would have been elected to the Senate from California in 1994, Al Checchi (D) would have been elected governor of that state in 1998 (or at least won the Democratic nomination), Blair Hull (D) would now be a senator from Illinois and Tony Sanchez (D) might have come close in his Texas gubernatorial bid in 2002.

So Watts' wallet gets my attention, but where do I look after that? His video is one of the few things on his Web site, other than a bunch of photographs of early campaign events, a bio and a donation form. So I watched it. The first half of the four-minute, 15 second video is straightforward enough. Watts introduces himself and talks about his education, his parents, his own family and his interest in public service. He's a trial lawyer, so it's not surprising that he's poised, articulate and polished. The second half of the video probably is the silliest, most transparent attempt to deliver a message I have ever seen.

Watts wants us to know that he is a "fighter" and a "leader," and he apparently thinks that viewers of his video are a little dense. You'd either have to be in a coma or not understand English to miss Watts' message. The Democratic hopeful uses a form of the word "fight" 11 times in the last two minutes and 15 seconds of the video. And he uses a form of the word "leader" another eight times during that same period. In one section of the video lasting 37 seconds, Watts uses the word "fighter" six times -- an average of once every 6.17 seconds:

"I have been a fighter my entire career, fighting for the rights of average, working families here in Texas. And I have proven that I will stay in that fight and give it my all until we win. Texans are looking for a Senator who is a leader, who will fight for them. Someone who will fight for families here in Texas rather than special interests there in Washington. I am certain that as we travel around the state and see more and more good Texans, that my message of real leadership and real change in Washington is a message that is going to hit home here in Texas. I am confident that Texans will join me in this fight."

There are plenty of attributes that voters want in their candidates. They certainly want leaders and, at least now, forces for change. I certainly wouldn't criticize Watts or any candidate for mentioning them. It's the way he talks about them that is so aggravating. It sounds as if he thinks he's the first guy to run on those buzzwords.

I'm not certain whether Watts' rhetoric is classic political boilerplate or an effort to neutralize the positioning of Noriega, a state legislator and veteran of the war in Afghanistan. If and when I meet Watts, I may have a completely different view of him and his prospects. But for now, I'd suggest that he re-do his video, making it more professional and more thoughtful.

Watts' video is here.

[Note: These are both videos intended strictly for internet use so don't post comments saying they're not good enough for TV. They are NOT TV ads.]

Tags: John Cornyn, Mikal Watts, Rick Noriega, TX-Sen (all tags)

Comments

27 Comments

Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Well speaking as one from the dirty south I would have to say Noriega's stuff looks good

by Trey Rentz 2007-08-01 10:49AM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

I much prefer Watts to Noriega and will probably be voting for him in the primary. He can self finance, saving a lot of time, and happens to be pro-life. Go ahead, flame away.

Let's face a fact that is sad but true; no hispanic man, who is relying on netroots for cash, can win a statewide election in Texas. Even a well financed hispanic will have problems in a statewide race in Texas.

So, could we perhaps, just once, pick the wonky white guy with a lot of money...so that we could maybe unseat this Bush puppet?

by kupo 2007-08-01 11:36AM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary
    Are you crazy?  Texas has loads of Hispanic voters who are looking for an inspiring Democrat.  Rick Noriega is that Democrat.  The last thing we need is another white millionaire who looks and talks like the Republican incumbent.  There's a first time for everything, and I think Texas can elect a Hispanic Democrat statewide this cycle.
    I keep hearing about the changing demographics of Louisiana due to the Katrina catastrophe.  Now where did that voting bloc go?  Texas!  Who is going to register these new-to-Texas voters?  I hope Noriega makes the Katrina catastrophe a part of his campaign.  
by cilerder86 2007-08-01 11:49AM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

How is Rock Noriega "that" Democrat? He served in the war, and I commend him for that. However, so did netroots favorite John Courage (who, much to my frustration, seemed to get more focus than Chris Bell)...and we all saw how that turned out. Playing the "I'm a vet" card isn't as successful as some would like to believe.

Then, like it or not, you have to look at the financial resources. Watts can self-finance a campaign and thus has more time to actually campaign. He doesn't have to pray that Netroots comes through for him. I am not troubled by his financial status, I still think he would make a good voice for populism, like fellow millionaire John Edwards.

While I don't know how you can "look" like a Republican (unless you are implying that any non-hispanic is too Republican for you), I can assure you that Watts does not talk like a Republican. He's as fiscally progressive as any of us here and opposes the border wall. He happens to be pro-life, like myself, but if you are going to vote against a candidate based on one social issue...then you are more suited to the politics of the Republican Party and should probably vote for Cornyn.

I like Noriega, I really do, but we have a more electable candidate that can self-finance in the running. I would rather give Watts a chance, then watch another netroots favorite get trounced by 10+ points at the hands of a half-ass Republican on election day.

by kupo 2007-08-01 12:17PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Kinda like how netroots favorites Tester and Webb lost on election day. Get over yourself.

btw- let us know when you turn 18.

by The 13th Texan 2007-08-01 12:38PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

  Your profile says it all.  Go back to myspace.

by cilerder86 2007-08-01 12:50PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Now, now. There is no need for us to sling mud around like this, we can have a intelligent conversation without doing so. I may be young, but I am as capable of reading the paper and keeping up as the rest of you.

As for Webb and Tester, those situations are a little different. As much as I respect Jim Webb, he probably wouldn't have won had it not been for Allen's inexcusable gaffe. Tester on the other hand was running against a man engulfed in corruption, which made his goal more achievable. John Cornyn is a generic Republican in Texas, and thus will have the upper hand in the race. For that reason, I would prefer that we nominate a candidate that has a good chance at unseating Cornyn.

by kupo 2007-08-01 01:00PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Were you aware Webb won his primary without running a single TV ad?

by The 13th Texan 2007-08-01 01:04PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

I wasn't aware of that, and that's very impressive. None-the-less, that's a primary...not a general, which has been the focus of my argument here. My candidate winning his primary is far less important to me than my party winning the general. I have no doubt that Noriega could win the primary, in fact...I would say that it's likely. None-the-less, he would have a much harder time in the general than a candidate like Watts would.

by kupo 2007-08-01 01:08PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

and since that is based on your many years of experience in Texas politics, I'm sure that regular readers will bow to your wisdom.

Then again, it is kind of cute to find someone out there who actually supports Joe Biden.

silly populist, you.

by The 13th Texan 2007-08-01 01:13PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Again, must we be so rude? I am just offering my take on it. I have not thrown anything negative at you.

Plus, Joe Biden? My candidate for 2008 is John Edwards.

by kupo 2007-08-01 01:26PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

If your concern is that the money won't be there if Noriega wins the nomination, I hope the fact that Ben Barnes & Co. (basically all those who have the ability to bankroll Dem candidates in Texas) have stated earlier in the year that they will donate millions upon millions for the Democratic nominee in the general, REGARDLESS of who he/she ends up being, will go a ways in easing those concerns.  Does it?

by Leviathan 2007-08-01 01:15PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

That's great to hear. None-the-less, money isn't my only reason for supporting Watts. I happen to align more with Watts on the issues than I do with Noriega. Unfortunately for me though, being that I am a younger person, I am unable to properly research the candidates and make informed decisions. I am probably just mistaken.

by kupo 2007-08-01 01:33PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Not sure if those last few sentences were snark or not (guessing so, seeing as that I'm 19 and feel confident in my abilities to research political candidates, lol), but that's great that Watts is your candidate of choice (no pun intended, honestly!) in the primary.  I was only commenting on your concerns about money being a hindrance for Noriega in a general election.  Good luck, from one young Texan to another.

by Leviathan 2007-08-01 01:49PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Cornyn is a type of Republican that may have a Macaca Moment- similar to Sessions(AL) and Chambliss(GA). However unlike Mr Macaca himself. Texas,Georgia,and Alabama are strong Republican states. Virginia is trending Democratic.

by nkpolitics 2007-08-02 03:52AM | 0 recs
Watts a chance to do what?

He's already shooting himself in the foot with voters in Victoria.

Also, while John Courage was a great candidate, your parallel is incorrect.

Lt. Colonel Noriega is still in the National Guard, was activated for service in Afghanistan, and just last week took command of  the 1st Battalion, 141st Infantry Regiment. This battalion can trace its history back to the Republic of Texas.

If the ability to self finance were all it took to win in Texas, we would have re-elected Governor Tony Sanchez in 2006.

by boadicea 2007-08-06 05:55AM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

You must not pay attention to democratic primary politics in this state.   Not too long ago an underfunded dem named Victor Morales won the senate nom for our party.  Last time I checked he was hispanic.

by Morter Forker 2007-08-01 12:00PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

I was speaking in terms of the general election, and we all remember how well Victor Morales' campaign for senate did. For those of you that don't, Morales lost by roughly 9 points.

by kupo 2007-08-01 12:20PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

And what was the last rich white guy that won statewide office in Texas?

Oh that's right...

by The 13th Texan 2007-08-01 12:34PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary
victor morales also only spent $900,000 and got 45% of the vote.
His namesake Dan Morales won statewide (AG) in 1990 and 1994 rather handily.
by Texas Nate 2007-08-01 01:17PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

victor morales was the last democrat to come within 5 points statewide of 50%

by Morter Forker 2007-08-01 01:18PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary
yup.
2002 was a big disaster and we didn't really field a slate in 2006.
by Texas Nate 2007-08-02 01:57AM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary
Being Pro-life means using police to impose pregnancy on women because women aren't adults, and can not use their own minds to determine the use of their own bodies.

I support the implantation of viable fetuses into anyone who calls themselves pro-life.

If you will carry to term and support any fetus we surgically implant, you may call yourself prolife.

No other avenue is available. No arguments are allowed, and jail is the only recourse.

Otherwise please shut up.
by inexile 2007-08-02 02:57PM | 0 recs
Why do you prefer Watts?

Is the wallet appeal the only one you think counts in this primary?

Forget the flamebait.  Make the case for why Mikal Watts, who has never held or even run for public office, is a better prospect for Senator than a  5 term legislator with military experience and a strong resume as a community leader.

I'll be here waiting.

by boadicea 2007-08-06 05:48AM | 0 recs
Not Watts.

Watts isn't different enough from Box Turtle Cornyn to earn my (or any other progressive's) support.

He's donated five-figure sums to Republicans Dewhurst and Abbott, considers homosexuality a "lifestyle choice", and like you said is anti-choice.

The last thing we need in Texas is to replace John Cornyn with Joe Lieberman (or worse).  Watts as the nominee would be a disaster for Texas Democrats, who can ill afford any more wipeouts at the statewide level.

Someone needs to convince him of these facts before he throws his millions of his dollars down a hole of his own digging.

by PDiddie 2007-08-01 12:40PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary
Texas has elected Hispanics to important state-wide offices.  On top of that, Noriega clearly understands how to message his relatively populist in decidedly not-populist east-Texas.  
  I think many of us underestimate what a rare jewel Noriega is in my former home region.  Not only is he a policy wonk that has a genuine command of the issues, but he does an extrodinarily effective job of communicated the issues and his bio.
by jefedelosjefes64105 2007-08-01 12:51PM | 0 recs
Re: Online Video in the Texas Senate Primary

Just saw Col. Rick Noriega at YearlyKos interviewed in a spontaneous online video link ( try ustream.tv and click yearlykos )- good looking articulate and progressive, this seems to be the candidate to support.

ricknoriega.com is the place to look.

He looks younger and thinner than in his campaign site photos, that should be fixed but he has great presence. Very electable.

Hopefully he'll get some contributions from the blogosphere.

by inexile 2007-08-02 03:05PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------