Another GOP Rep Lines Up for Futile Challenge to Harkin

It has been said that Tom Harkin is the place Republican Congressmen go to end their careers on Capitol Hill. To date Harkin has in fact defeated more sitting House Republicans -- Bill Scherle, Roger Jepsen, Tom Tauke, Jim Lightfoot, and Greg Ganske -- than any Democrat in the history of the United States Senate. And it now looks like we might be adding one more name to that list next November. Jane Norman has the details for The Des Moines Register.

Republican Rep. Tom Latham of Iowa said today he has moved his residence from Alexander, in rural Franklin County, south to Ames, in Story County.

[...]

There has also been speculation that Latham might mount a challenge to incumbent Sen. Tom Harkin, a Democrat up for re-election in 2008.

Latham, who had $214,000 in campaign money in the bank as of March 31, said his move had nothing to do with a more central location for a statewide bid.

However, asked if he's looking at a run for the Senate seat, Latham said: "I have not said no."

But he added: "That doesn't mean I've said yes."

The prospect of a Senate run by Latham is somewhat good news on a number of fronts for the Democrats.

When it comes to the race for the United States Senate in Iowa this cycle, Republicans have often been fooled by Harkin's progressive streak and his often unimpressive polling numbers that he can be easily defeated. As was noted above, five sitting Republican Congressmen have already lost races to Harkin -- and often ones they believed they should have won.

I do not mean to prejudge the outcome of next fall's election, but I am highly skeptical that Latham is the man to break the Republicans' bad streak against Harkin -- who, I might add, has seen his approval rating seemingly settle in the mid- to upper-50s after previously settling in the lower- to mid-50s earlier in the year, according to SurveyUSA polling. Latham's roughly $200,000 on hand is not nearly the base upon which to run a campaign against an entrenched incumbent, particularly not one who has close to $2 million in the bank. Compounding the difficulty for Latham would be the fact that Iowa trended notieceably and decidedly towards the Democrats in 2006, with the Dems winning the governorship, picking up two congressional seats and gaining control over both the state House and the state Senate -- the first time the Democrats in the state have controlled the Governor's mansion and both chambers of the state legislature since Lyndon Johnson was President.

But even better than the fact that Harkin would not likely have too much of a problem dispelling with a challenge from Latham, a Senate bid by the Congressman would open up Iowa's 4th congressional district, which leans neither towards the Republicans nor the Democrats in presidential elections, according to the Cook Partisan Voting Index. Given the aforementioned trend in the Hawkeye state, coupled with the fact that the Democrats currently hold a strong lead in the generic congressional ballot question, it would be fair to say that Iowa 4 would be one of the Democrats' top pick-up opportunities in 2008 should Latham decide to run for the Senate.

Latham still might not make the plunge, as indicated by his second quote in the article above. But here's to hoping that he will.

Tags: House 2008, IA-04, IA-Sen, Iowa, Senate 2008 (all tags)

Comments

10 Comments

Re: Another GOP Rep Lines Up

It would shock me if Latham takes a shot at Harkin. He must hate life in the minority in the House for him to be even considering it.

He keeps a very low profile and is certainly not a guy who would give Harkin a run for his money. Latham rarely makes headlines even in his own district. He is barely known in vote-rich eastern Iowa.

by desmoinesdem 2007-06-08 05:21PM | 0 recs
Re: Latham vs Harkin proabaly not.

Tom Latham represents the 4th District which is mostly rural.  desmoinesdem is correct he is not well known outside his district which is L shaped and wraps around Polk County (Des Moines).

We are supposed to use an impartial process to draw district boundaries but it looks like a Republican stronghold to me.
He won easily in 2006 when he was opposed by Dr. Spencer a neurologist with no political experience.

It does not make any sense for the GOP to give up a safe seat in the house for a very long shot run for the senate.

by JSN 2007-06-08 06:47PM | 0 recs
Re: Latham vs Harkin proabaly not.

Life in the minority in the house has got to truly suck. You know that your side is almost always going to lose and you'll likely have little impact on drafting legislation or getting your desired changes included. If you think your party is likely to remain in the minority for a long period I can see why you'd make the play for the upper house where even in the minority you get a lot more input into legislation.

by Quinton 2007-06-08 06:50PM | 0 recs
Re: Latham vs Harkin proabaly not.

It's because it is NOT a safe seat. Districts 1 and 2 favor democrats (both were take overs from republicans last year with district 1 being open).

District 3 and 4 are both 50/50 with the slightest of democratic leans. 3 is held by Bowsell (D) and is about D+1, 4 is Latham and is D+0.1. This is the district in question. The Democrats in Iowa had enough on their plate last year to focus on Latham by holdign the gov. mansion, getting 2 congressional districts, the state senate and holding the state house. The probably picked up several other state wide seats, but I dunno those stats off hand.

District 5 however is a republican stronghold, King is not vulnerable unless he screws up somehow.

National PVIs:
IA-1 - D+1, Democratic pickup for open seat in 2006, Bruce Braely (D)
IA-2 - D+7, Democratic pickup from incumbent in 2006, Dave Loosenback (D)
IA-3 - D+1, Democratic held, Leonard Boswell (D), assumed office 1996
IA-4 - D+0, Republican held, Tom Latham (R), assumed office 1994
IA-5 - R+8, Republican held, Steve King (R), assumed office 2003

by Trowaman 2007-06-08 09:35PM | 0 recs
Re: Latham vs Harkin proabaly not.

*IA-1 has a PVI of D+5, not 1

by Trowaman 2007-06-08 09:37PM | 0 recs
Re: Another One Bites the Dust

Selden Spencer did a pretty reasonable job against Latham and had one hell of a stump speech.  The video was available for a while on the Des Moines Register site (as well as those of the other House candidates and the Governor candidates).  His was easily the best.

More importantly, this brings the running count of rumored retirements among Republican House members up to 32.  I took the comments for all 202 seats won by Republicans in 2006 and added in my memory of what I had seen of active scandal or other rumors.  By comparison, in 2006 21 Republicans and 9 Democrats did not run for their seat in the general election (that includes a few primary losses).

Given their cash shortage, it would be hard to mount a major challenge in the 30 new seats won by Democratic challengers if Republicans had to defend 30 vacancies.  Of course not all rumors will turn out to be true but new issues will push the number forward.  Rove and the White House pushed hard in 2006 to limit the number of retirements so this may, in part, be a delayed effect.

by David Kowalski 2007-06-09 04:43AM | 0 recs
Re: Another One Bites the Dust

Can you link or post to this list of Republicans who have expressed interest in hanging up their bat and going home? I'd be very itnerested to see the list.

by Trowaman 2007-06-09 11:37AM | 0 recs
Redistricting

With Iowa standing to lose a seat in the next redistricting, cementing the Dems hold on central Iowa is important.

Iowa redistricting is done by a nonpartisan commission.  I expect that the commission will create one swing district in Central Iowa, centered on Des Moines and roughly equal parts of the present 3rd and 4th districts, with the 1st, 2nd and current 5th each expanding their boundaries and keeping their current occupants relatively safe.  I also expect that Leonard Boswell, now representing the 3rd, will pick that year to retire.

If Latham's still around, he's the favorite to stay in the new 3rd, leaving the House delegation at 2-2. If he runs against Harkin, and a Democrat picks up the current 4th, that Democrat will be the favorite, and the House delegation will be 3-1. (4-5 prior to redistricting).

by admiralnaismith 2007-06-09 08:15AM | 0 recs
Re: Redistricting

and if Boswell chooses to retire in 2008 (as i think he should), and is replaced by a democrat, then it'll be a... toss-up?

by KainIIIC 2007-06-09 10:26AM | 0 recs
Run Latham Run!
It would be a dream come true for Latham to challenge Harkin.  He represents my hometown in north-central Iowa, and it would be a truly competitive open seat.  As much as I like Selden Spencer, a farmer would be a stronger candidate in the district.
As desmoinesdem points out, Latham is unknown in eastern Iowa.  Republicans that have given Harkin a scare have had a base there.  Given the political climate, and Iowans' restlessness over Iraq, the race wouldn't even be close.
I doubt Latham runs though.
by ChgoSteve 2007-06-09 12:01PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------