A Room Of One's Own

Right now, I am at my younger brother's house in Rochester, NY. Despite its small size, a metropolitan area of just under 1.1 million people, of all cities in the nation, Rochester will actually be at the center of Democratic House pickup opportunities in 2008. In addition to Louise Slaughter's district, three key districts extend into the city: NY-25, NY-26, and NY-29. In 2006, Democrats lost these three seats, combined, by less than 10,000 votes. Fortunately, the city is well served by an excellent local blog, Rochester Turning, which has roughly the same amount of traffic as The Albany Project. The infrastructure, opportunities and, with Dan Maffei and Eric Massa both running again, candidates are in place to make Rochester a city to watch over the next two years. Also, from what I have heard, rumors of Louise Slaughter endorsing Eric Massa's millionaire primary challenger are simply not true.

One thing I have noticed during my time here relates more broadly to the "short head" and "long tail" phenomenon in the progressive political blogosphere. I have been up since about 8 a.m. trying to blog, but I have found it difficult to complete article of any length of depth of insight. The "problem," if I can ever forgive myself for calling him such, has been my ultra-cute and lovable three year old nephew Liam, who has an insatiable desire to play with me while I am around. As you can see in the picture on the right, in addition to the fact that I don't look very good in the morning, as I was trying to blog, he jumped up on the couch with me, urging me to play with, among other things, his Darth Vader Mr. Potatohead.

As a single guy with no roommates and no one to support, this was not something I am used to dealing with during my writing. However, it is precisely these sorts of barriers that have prevent many people from entering the "short head" elite of highly-trafficked, highly-linked progressive blogs. While I can dedicate myself to undisturbed writing with broadband internet access for up to twelve hours a days if necessary, people with families, other forms of employment, or limited internet access cannot. Well beyond issues over blogrolls, hyperlink patterns and search engine optimization, the ability to write full-time is the main advantage that the "short head," (or, if you prefer, the so-called "A-list") has over "long tail" blogs in terms of content production. If I had a family, if my job did provide me with regular internet access, or if I simply could not afford to live on the salary of a full-time blogger, it would be entirely impossible for me to meet the content production requirements necessary to stay in "the short head." I'll have a lot more on this in an academic-style article coming out in a few weeks, but having a room of one's own to blog is the main barrier to entry into the "short head," not hyperlink patterns.

This actually relates to a problem facing our House challengers in Rochester and Western New York as well. Last night, as the picture on the left shows, I spent more than two hours chatting with Dan Maffei at a coffee shop in Webster, New York (second picture). Simply that I spent more than two hours talking with someone who I had never previously met in person is stunning for a generally shy person like me, but we just couldn't stop talking. Dan, who lost in 2006 by less than 1,000 votes against a long-term incumbent who wasn't even challenged in 2004, is a truly brilliant candidate who I think the blogosphere would see eye to eye with on a wide range of strategic and ideological principles (more on that later). He also, as he says, has to live on a salary equivalent to a graduate student during the campaign because he is fairly young, not from a wealthy background, and has dedicated himself to service and activism all of his life. It is in this way that those trying to enter the upper echelons of public service face similar problems to those trying to enter the upper echelons of the progressive blogosphere. Most people are simply not in a position where they can spend years dedicating themselves to a project, whether running for office or blogging full-time, which consumes over sixty hours a week and delivers fairly low pay in return. This problem is perhaps particularly severe in a region like Western New York, which is suffering a slight, overall population loss and extensive brain-drain among the demographics that can often make up the core of progressive netroots and grassroots communities in any given region. In fact, in order to find the type of engaging, creative employment commensurate with his education level in the Rochester area, my younger brother has actually decided to run for Monroe County legislature, and on Friday received the Democratic Party endorsement for his seat. Other creative class types looking for ways to support a family might simply have left the area. It is perhaps remarkable that the area is still able to produce excellent, non-self funding candidates like Eric Massa and Dan Maffei, and organically grown, progressive blogs like Rochester Turning, at all.

The lack of "a room of one's own" from which to blog or to campaign is, I believe, the major barrier to entry to regular participation in the blogosphere, and perhaps to the higher levels of politics in general. It is also, I believe, the main cause for the perceived lack of diversity in the progressive blogosphere, and the increasing ossification of the "short head." I am surprised people don't talk about this more, considering how much spleen we vent on things like blogrolls, which don't have nearly as much impact on traffic, and considering how there seems to be widespread agreement on the need for public financing of federal campaigns that will allow less wealthy candidates and donors a more equitable political playing field. If someone can blog full-time, that person's blog will have a competitive advantage over other blogs that can't afford full-time writers.

Speaking of which, I have to run, and familial duties will keep me from blogging pretty much the day. Maybe it is good for me to learn how the other half of the blogosphere lives.

Tags: Blogosphere, Dan Maffei, NY-25, Rochester (all tags)

Comments

25 Comments

For someone with no time to think today

That was a really insightful diary.  

by lisadawn82 2007-06-04 09:37AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

My daughter is turning 2 tomorrow, and she wants to play all the time.  It is to the point where I can pretty much only post late at night/very early in the morning or while at work.  

When I am at home on my laptop she comes over and wants me to load the Hi-5 or Elmo site.  I showed her the "Hillary Clinton" site, but all it gets me is a blank stare and demands to "change it."  Hmmm.   Then again, I get the same reaction when I show her the MyDD website.   :-)  

by georgep 2007-06-04 09:44AM | 0 recs
5.5 / 3.5 / -0.5
coffee breaks are a family man's best blogging friend.
kids
by Robert P 2007-06-04 11:01AM | 0 recs
Re: 5.5 / 3.5 / -0.5

My wife, daughter, and I went to a professional photographer and decided against such a shot. That pose gives me the creeps.

by NCDem 2007-06-04 01:26PM | 0 recs
Re: 5.5 / 3.5 / -0.5

One person's creeps is another person's joy.

by Robert P 2007-06-05 05:43AM | 0 recs
Re: 5.5 / 3.5 / -0.5

True 'dat. I'm just sayin' though, womb-worship is weird... to me (and my wife).

Your kids are cute. Recessive bh/be genes for sure.

by NCDem 2007-06-05 06:01AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

It's a 'Darth Tater'-- my 3 & 5 y.o. nephews love theirs, too.

by latts 2007-06-04 09:56AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

NY-25 is one of just five House districts represented by a Republican but won by John Kerry in 2004.  Five of those eight very winnable districts are in the Northeast: PA-6, PA-15, DE-At Large, NY-25 and CT-4. For those who wonder, the other three Kerry districts held by GOPers are NM-1 (Heather Wilson), WA-8 (Dave Reichert), and IL-10 (Kirk).

Prior to 1992, only one Democrat had swept the Northeast's electoral votes in nearly 200 years (1796 to 1988), LBJ.  Since then, Democrats have swept in three of four elections with Al Gore's 8,000 vote loss being the lone exception.  

The Northeast has 92 House members (68 Democrats, 24 Republicans).  After the 1994 Contract With America election, Republicans held 46 seats (Democrats had 52, Bernie Sanders as an Independent held one).  With redistricting playing a role (loss of rural districts), Republicans were down to 35 by 2006 and lost 11 seats (plus Bernie's seat going Democratic).  No incumbent Democrat in the Northeast got less than 60% and an astounding 42 got 70% or more.

We really have an opportunity to nearly eliminate the Republican Party in the Northeast on the federal level in 2008 (and GOPers are down to Connecticut, Vermont, and Rhode Island at the Governor level).  Easily the strongest Republican district in the region covers Maryland's Eastern Shore, traditionally more Southern than northern.

I can go over them district by district (all 24).  In my mind, at least, the strongest deterrent to another big regional pickup would be the nomination of Rudy Giuliani.  Fred Thompson or Mitt Romney or the aging John McCain lack the magic here.  I am increasingly coming to the conclusion that for some unknown reason, the Giuliani campaign is self destructing in Iowa and will not get off the ground.

So much of MyDD has become a flame war between Obama and Edwards partisans.  The real big story is happening at a lower level.  The end of Walsh, Shays, Gerlach, Dent, Castle, Ferguson, Garrett, Reynolds, Kuhl, and English (to name the ten weakest GOP House members in the region) would be huge.  So would the fall of Sununu and Collins.

Nixon was technically a NY resident when elected but he only lived in the region (NYC, retired to NJ).  The last real Northeasterner to run as a Republican nominee for President was Giuliani clone Tom Dewey (1944,1948);  the last to win was Calvin Coolidge in 1924.  The country club wing of the GOP is peeling off and the "rock ribbed" independents of New England left for Perot in 1992 and never returned (Perot finished second in Maine with over 30% of the vote).

by David Kowalski 2007-06-04 10:02AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Gore lost NH by 8,000 votes and took the remaining 10 states plus DC.  I thought I said that above but failed to complete my thought.

by David Kowalski 2007-06-04 10:05AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

I think Castle (R-DE-at-large) is pretty safe. He always does very well and is fairly moderate, isn't he?

by Quinton 2007-06-04 08:12PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Castle's in good shape iof he runs.  He does have some health issues and Democrats would be favored for an open seat.

by David Kowalski 2007-06-05 12:02AM | 0 recs
What a literary place this is!

First it was the Martin Luther allusion, now it's Virginia Woolf.

Some classy joint you've made this place, buddy!

(The fact I recognize the allusion doesn't mean I've, y'know, read any of the oeuvre. Just saying...)

by skeptic06 2007-06-04 10:30AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Aren't you part of the western NY brain drain problem.

by Bob Brigham 2007-06-04 10:55AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Sure.  My wife wrote her first book when she was single and living alone; since our daughter was born, she can write her books (and her blog) because we can afford a sitter to come over in the afternoons to watch our daughter while Jen goes to the local coffeeshop and writes.

And at this point, whenever my 4-y.o. daughter sees me on a computer, she will demand that I switch over to Noggin.com so she can play games with Dora.

by Adam B 2007-06-04 10:57AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Is Mark running against Quatro then?

by sayhar 2007-06-04 11:31AM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Yes.  When the petitions come out this weekend in force Mark Bowers will be the Democratic candidate against Dan Quatro in Monroe LD 15.

by Mark J. Bowers 2007-06-04 04:11PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Nice.

by sayhar 2007-06-04 04:18PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Good post.

by Korha 2007-06-04 11:36AM | 0 recs
Cute pic

I mean the one with the baby ofcourse.  

Enjoy these early years while they stumble and bumble. My 7 year old niece thinks tag never ends til she says so haha.

by optimusprime 2007-06-04 01:25PM | 0 recs
Not only blogging

Welcome to parenthood by proxy, Chris. Only for me it all things unicorn and pink.

You speak of "if you had a family" you probably couldn't do what you do. But realize something - it's not "if" but "when" you have a family.

I'd love to not only blog fulltime, but work in politics full time. Best of both worlds. But I'm not in my 20's anymore.  I - and my familiy - can't afford the transition it would take. If I had to guess, this would be the reason I'd give as to why we see bloggers come and go so rapidly. I coudn't maintain the hours required to blog, work for a campaign, go to grad school, work full time at my job, and spend any time at all with my family. Physically or mentally. When it came down to what I was going to cut out (or reduce), it was blogging.

by michael in chicago 2007-06-04 01:27PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

That's great!  I actually interned with Louise in Rochester.

by Mark J. Bowers 2007-06-04 04:12PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

I seem to remember reading that the Republicans have been very skillful in encouraging and facilitating college Republicans & young Republicans and helping them up the ladder to political prominence.  We Democrats have to get better at this.  Some of the Democratic groups with money need to fund more internships, blogs, entry level jobs for young Democrats.  Otherwise, for many of the reasons above, good people will drop out of the system.  We need to think about ways to encourage young people to be active Dems, and this means paying them a living wage to do so.  

by MVD 2007-06-04 04:23PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

Make sure you eat a garbage plate while in town.

by rallydemocrat 2007-06-04 05:47PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

This one really strikes a chord with me. The problem I have is staying "current" with a thread while also  taking care of children, etc. Blog conversations come and go very fast, and usually the main comment period is long gone before I have a chance to catch up.

by Mark Wallace 2007-06-04 07:23PM | 0 recs
Re: A Room Of One's Own

good post--one thing I noticed though was that your #s are a bit off.

Maffei shocked the world when he lost by around 3500 votes.  Massa came up short by near around 6000.  Jack Davis in the race against Reynolds lost by more than that.  

Anyways, collectively, we're talking around 15 or 16,000 votes out of somewheres around 600,000 cast, so your point is well taken.

by Sheffield 2007-06-04 08:25PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------