Dem Turnout Way Up?
by Chris Bowers, Wed May 03, 2006 at 08:56:44 AM EDT
Indiana looked about the same for both parties. The most surprising race there was probably in the 8th district in Evansville and Terra Haute, a swing seat that voted 62-38 for Bush in 2004. Neither party's candidate had an opponent, and incumbent Republican John Hostettler (one of six GOP votes against the Iraq War in 2003) got 27,366 votes. But Democrat Brad Ellsworth got 43,213 votes. Wow--those are very encouraging numbers, and support the data from Gallup yesterday that Democratic voters are much more enthusiastic about voting this year than are Republicans. Maybe our turnout problems are not so bad. The numbers in the OH-06 further emphasize what I was saying earlier today: competitive, contested primaries work. They force the cream to rise to the top, and improve the Democratic operation in the area with the contested primary. There is no way that Democratic turnout would have been so high in that district unless Charlie Wilson had been forced to get his act together and build a real ground game and grassroots operation.
These are only two states, but maybe our turnout situation actually look pretty good for 2006. I think we may have been sucked into a bit of "the sky is falling" type analysis because of faulty comparisons. Either we were comparing Democratic turnout to previous years (as we did in Illinois and Texas), or we were comparing Democratic turnout to national partisan indexes instead of the more appropriate local indexes (the C-50 special election). All of that was comparing apples to oranges. The real "apples to apples" comparison should always have been to check only contested Democratic primaries versus contested Republican primaries or uncontested Democratic primaries versus uncontested Republican primaries in the same district, and then compare Democratic turnout relative to Republican turnout in those districts relative to expected turnout. Only then can you eliminate all of the variables. In both OH-06 and IN-08, we have just that sort of apples to apples comparison, and it looks very, very good for Democrats.
I am not ready to start planning the transition to power, like some Dems, but I certainly like the way things are going right now. We are still six months from Election Day, but at least for right now, the national wave and Indycrat realignment certainly seems to be a possibility.
Tags: House 2006, IN-08, OH-06, Primary Elections, turnout (all tags)









12 Comments