Elizabeth Bumiller's Disconnect from Reality

Stephen Colbert's incredible roast, where the room of pompous DC-tards wasn't laughing but everyone else was, has been seen several hundred thousand times on Youtube.  The stupid and hackish Bush impersonation, replete with such witticisms as Laura Bush is 'hot', isn't even listed.  The people choose Colbert.

And on cue, Elizabeth Bumiller's article on the evening in the New York Times doesn't even mention Colbert, and talks about how Bush stole the show.  Amazing.  Ridiculous.  In a few months, the insiders at the dinner will be claiming that they thought Colbert was terrific, that they were the only one laughing.  That's how these people work.  They'll hear about the legendary Colbert performance, and they'll rewrite history to make themselves seem savvy enough to 'get the joke'.

Anyway, it doesn't matter.  This is the gasp of the royal pretensions of the punditocracy.  And Colbert laid them bare, brutally. Thank you, Stephen.

Tags: Elizabeth Bumiller, New York Times (all tags)

Comments

9 Comments

Making the Punditocracy laugh.

Anybody remember when Bush had them rolling in the aisles, with Missing WMD jokes.

I do. Take a look at the video to see for yourself.

http://www.musicforamerica.org/bushjoke

by FranzHartl 2006-05-01 08:17AM | 0 recs
Don't blame Bumiller...

I'd kinda worked out some time ago that Bumiller was Fluffer-in-Chief to the presidential ego.

Why? Because Keller and Sulzberger like it that way.

Why? Because business ain't going so good for the NYT Co, flattering the prez comes cheap, and insurgency (for any top paper, not just the Times) is a path to ruin.

In fact, I'm not sure whether there was any period, except for late Vietnam-Watergate, when any of them have taken an insurgent tack.

For true suckupmanship, rummage about the Virtual Vietnam Archive (albert m colegrove is a good search) and pull up the 1959 reports of the subcommittees of the House Foreign Affairs and Senate Foreign Relations Committees for an insight into how the US media's early anilingualism set up the nation for the subsequent war.

(The Times' Tillman Durbin's work (some reproduced in the reports) matches Bumiller's in sheer ghastliness. Colegrove, by the way, was the one journo who dared to call the emperor (ie, Ngo Dinh Diem) naked. He was scarcely heard of again, as I recall...)

by skeptic06 2006-05-01 08:28AM | 0 recs
Actually, it was made official in 2004...

In an elimination tournament Matt Taibbi conducted in the New York Press in the weeks preceding the election, Elizabeth Bumiller won the title of Worst Campaign Journalist in America.  She out-hacked everybody else, though in the end, appropriately enough, she beat Howard Fineman only by default when he failed to file.  

by antidoto 2006-05-01 08:39AM | 0 recs
Re: Elizabeth Bumiller's Disconnect from Reality

I urge you all to launch missives about this to the public editor (public@nytimes.com).  Here is my email-sent before I read any blogs this AM:

Dear Public Editor:

I am astonished to say the least that the coverage of the White House Correspondents' dinner failed to mention what has become the talk of the internet: Stephen Colbert's gutsy performance in which he called Pres. Bush, the press, Sen. McCain, Mayor Ray Nagin of New Orleans, and many others.  It may well be that the discomforting truth behind Colbert's performance is more than the  media can handle, particularly the Times, whose prewar coverage led by Judith Miller is more than a little embarassing.  However, to make absolutely NO mention of Colbert's rip roaring performance is to suggest as many have the the mainstream media is too uncomfortably in a collaboratory mode with the political leadership.  Did Bush and his advisors threaten papers with cutting off access if they mentioned Colbert?  Or is this another all too familiar example of self-censorship?  

In recent months the Times has done an admirable job of recovering from the excesses of the pre-war coverage which also included a fawning review of Colin Powell's UN speech.  I have been pleased with the coverage of the NSA scandal, and pleased with the excellent editorial attacks on the excesses of the Bush administration.  However, to ignore Colbert's performance is, in my mind, inexcusable.

At the very least, the amazing internet response to Colbert deserves a story in the Arts section.

by calscientist 2006-05-01 08:50AM | 0 recs
Re: Elizabeth Bumiller's Disconnect from Reality

Will someone please, please, please explain to me what kind of future we have as a free country when the mainstream press can't even report a roast with even the remotest degree of accuracy?

by Drama Queen 2006-05-01 12:02PM | 0 recs
"pompous DC-tards"

Ahhhh Hahahahahahahahahaha...

by cerebrocrat 2006-05-01 01:01PM | 0 recs
Re: Elizabeth Bumiller's Disconnect from Reality

by Pravin 2006-05-01 02:13PM | 0 recs
Re: Elizabeth Bumiller's Disconnect from Reality

Critics of Colbert who say he bombed because no one in the audience laughed are missing the point. The audience in attendance wasn't the intended audience of his comedy routine. Colbert was deadly serious. He did not expect anyone in attendance to  laugh. Considering reports his timing was off at times, I doubt a professional like him would be off if his sole intention was to entertain. No, he was there to deliver a different kind of bomb - one that would shock the audience. Only an idiot would think he delivered that routine just to elicit laughter which is the assumption of those who say that the stunned silence was proof that he bombed.

I think Colbert's only real audience was himself and people who think like him. The joke was not the delivery, but the stunned silence of a washington elite that won't dare anger the president even in confrontational settings, let alone a formal dinner.

by Pravin 2006-05-01 02:18PM | 0 recs
Great, Great Points

The problem is that irony is a harsh mistress for a comedian. Colbert is working with a lot of double-layered irony. I wonder how many in the audience watch Faux News enought to get the send-ups?

by MetaData 2006-05-01 05:53PM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------