Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

Bob Novak likes to tell the Democrats what will make for winning strategy and what won't. David Brooks has a penchant for telling the Democrats where they are going wrong and how they can right their course. With so much unsolicited help emanating from the right, it's a wonder that Democrats don't listen to the near constant stream of advice of the Republican and conservative prognosticators. Take, for instance, the advice offered by Mike Murphy, a one-time advisor to John McCain and Mitt Romney, who thinks that the Democrats should tone down their planned four-day celebration marking the swearing in of the new Democratic Congress and the new Democratic Speaker, Nancy Pelosi.

"What? No fireworks?" he said. "I'm glad they canceled the tickertape parade. They probably couldn't find biodegradable tickertape and a hybrid convertible."

He said the schedule is "classic Pelosi."

"She's not known for a light touch," he said. "She has every right to throw a new-speaker celebration, but it's 500 percent from what is normal. It's an aggressive act to grab the spotlight. Sounds to me like there's nobody at the meetings saying, 'Maybe that's a little too much.' She's needs a deputy chief of staff from the 'It's Not About You' department."

"Instead of pinning medals on each other, maybe it's time for more seriousness and purpose," Murphy added. "Nobody voted for Nancy Pelosi as speaker; they voted for a change in Washington. For her to grab the spotlight seems like a cult of personality. I have a feeling that Steny Hoyer is probably having a quiet lunch with his family."

Mike Murphy and other Republicans don't want the Democrats to create a big media circus surrounding the first days of the 110th Congress, but their reasoning has nothing to do with what would be good for the Democratic Party, unsurprisingly. In fact -- and here's a shock -- Republicans usually speak in their own self interest when they are telling Democrats what they should do.

In this case, the Republicans are opposed to Pelosi's celebration because it offers her a chance to define herself to the American public before they have a chance to slime her beyond recognition. According to polling conducted this month, only about half of Americans rate the incoming Speaker either favorably or unfavorably, with the remainder either viewing her neutrally or not knowing enough about her to form an opinion. As such, if the first impression of Pelosi that the remaining half of Americans receive is one of a powerful, but fair Speaker passing popular legislation like ethics reform and a minimum wage increase, not only will it be difficult for Republicans to portray Pelosi as out of the mainstream but many Americans -- even including some Republican voters -- will no doubt come away with a positive impression of the Democratic leader.

This fact scares Republicans more than almost anything else. In the absence of a strong and recognizable Democratic leadership in Congress, President Bush might have the capacity to try to steamroll his opponents -- even with his dismal approval ratings -- simply because of his control over the bully pulpit. But if Nancy Pelosi and, to a lesser extent, Harry Reid are able to solidy themselves as not only household names but popular household names, a goal they can certainly forward by successfully laying out their vision and agenda during the first days of the new Congress, then the Democrats will be able to at least match President Bush and the conservative establishment blow-for-blow and have a real chance to come out on top, both in terms of legislation passed and momentum attained going into the 2008 presidential election.

Tags: House, Nancy Pelosi (all tags)

Comments

16 Comments

Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

Ummmm, if memory serves, Junior pulled out all the stops for his coronation in the midst of a deadly war of his own making.  Goose and gander time once again.  A Republican specialty.

by bajonimi 2006-12-23 06:14AM | 0 recs
Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

I believe much of that was paid for by private monies.

by Matt Stoller 2006-12-23 06:50AM | 0 recs
Who pays the bills for Pelosi's?

And who paid for Ginrich's? I don't know; I'm asking.

by stevehigh 2006-12-23 07:23AM | 0 recs
Make sure Reid remembers the electorate's will

It is important that Reid and Pelosi are empowered to take on the conservative establishment, but we must ensure that they remember why the Dems are now in control.

Harry Reid and other Democrats have expressed support for the notion of sending more troops to Iraq. They are not listening to the will of the people, whose opposition to the war gave them control of the Congress. Only 12% support sending more troops to Iraq -- the overwhelming majority want the troops to come home now.

Here are three things we can do about it:

1. Tell Senator Harry Reid you expect the Democrats to follow the clear wishes of the electorate and bring the troops home from Iraq. Call Reid at 202-224-2158 or 202-224-7003 or email his chief of staff at Susan_McCue@reid.senate.gov

2. Plan to mark the 3000th U.S. death with a vigil or other event in your community. Under the slogan, "Not One More Death, Not One More Dollar," the American Friends Service Committee is coordinating events all around the country. http://www.afsc.org/3000

3. Join United for Peace and Justice in Washington, D.C. on Saturday, January 27 for a massive peace march, calling on Congress to use their power to bring the troops home now. http://www.unitedforpeace.org

by srcnyc 2006-12-23 06:26AM | 0 recs
Slime defense

I agree Pelosi is right to attempt this, but there will be an attempt, as signaled by Murphy, to ridicule her as vain (just like a woman).

The best defense against this is to emphasize the historic importance of Pelosi as the first female speaker.

We would observe, respectfully, the same degree of ceremony if it were Deborah Pryce who were making history. Nancy Pelosi, who is not only the first woman to achieve this high and important office, but also the first Italian-American.

Pelosi, daughter of immigrant roots, and the mother and grandmother of five, is an inspiration to mothers, grandmothers and, especially, granddaughters everywhere, regardless of party.

Murphy and others are attacking Pelosi because of her gender and ethnicity, and that's just plain wrong. It's un-American. They should reflect that, with a vice-president in precarious health, and a president in danger of potential impeachment, that Rep. Pelosi might be president of the United States.

This is a time for women and their fathers, husbands and sons to rejoice, not a time for snide anti-female remarks. Women are only 15.5% of the House of Representative. We should encourage more young women--from both parties--to become active in politics and run for office.

by stevehigh 2006-12-23 07:06AM | 0 recs
Re: Slime defense ???

I don't know the best defense, but

effective message needs 24*7*365 attention and work.

I don't have confidence that the current DC leadership (Howard excluded) know how to do effective message - I've been underwhelmed for 6+ weeks.

I hope she / they pull it off -

from a thug perspective, a 4 day party is a perfect chance to throw the Dem message off the mark right outta the gate.

rmm.  

by seabos84 2006-12-23 09:00AM | 0 recs
Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

http://www.opendemocracy.net/democracy/r epublican_system_3197.jsp

"After the Republican sweep in 1994, Gingrich held a mad celebration featuring people dressed as the cartoon Power Rangers and Rush Limbaugh."

I wonder where Bob Novak and Mike Murphy were on this?

by Billmckern 2006-12-23 07:12AM | 0 recs
This is worth researching, esp. for pix

The Reps have already made the point that Gingrich's was only two days, not four.

We're going to have to push back, or Pelosi's message will be lost in "circus" coverage.

by stevehigh 2006-12-23 07:21AM | 0 recs
Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

Remember those polls about how the more that people knew that Republicans were in charge of congress, the more likely they were to vote Democrat?  I believe one of the writers here said (half seriously I assume) that we could just advertise "Republicans control congress" and win elections.  Looks like thats what they're doing, letting people know there is a change in leadership, and then legislating change.  Seems like a good idea to me.

by John Nicosia 2006-12-23 07:56AM | 0 recs
Any Move is Right Move w/ Messaging, which,

btw, has been dismal.

I did post on this earlier, and I think I got sent to the troll world, so I'm not going to bother repeating myself.

My fellow Dems, since I was 20 in 1980? have been super sensitive about their crappy messaging ability, preferring to hide behind big fancy degrees and big fancy papers as justification for not having easy effective message.

As someone who broke 50 grand once in my life, I wish the Dems were doing more than getting boxed around about this escalation in vietnam - I mean surge in Iraq - and countless other things from the wingnuts the last 6+ weeks.  

Can the sell the inauguration as the beginning of something new ...???

Well, given the shitty job they're doing on surge protection, I doubt it.

Message matters, and effective message has to have lots of nice fit together soundbites.

We have the truth, why can't we have effective message for talking to normal people ??

rmm.

by seabos84 2006-12-23 08:19AM | 0 recs
editing gaffes - oops.

there are several - this freaking 8 day flu thing sucks.  I can rarely edit online worth a crap when I am 'healthy'.

ugh.

rmm.

by seabos84 2006-12-23 08:28AM | 0 recs
Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

Glad someone else noticed those quotes from Mike Murphy.  My post is here.  Murphy is trying to make himself relevant again after retreating for a year following the disaster of a special election in California.  This sexist language is nothing new for him.  He is still pushing the SF liberal nonsense, the Republican spin about change, and tries to reignite the leadership battle all in a few short sentences.

by juls 2006-12-23 09:26AM | 0 recs
Dems early moves a definite risk

Not exactly that they're leading with their chin.

But they're also not exactly showing themselves risk-averse in their plans for starting off the 110th.

The Pelosi ballyhoo; plus running the Congress through the usual fallow period from swearing-in to SOTU; working more hours a week; and making a production number out of the ethics bill (with different freshmen introducing different elements on the House floor):

The overall effect should be to increase the Dems' profile (Pelosi's in particular, as noted upthread); which is good if everything runs like clockwork, but not so good if the Dems going in are not quite ready for prime time.

(Which would be no great criticism, given that they've been in the minority for 12 years.)

Now, on other hand, we're told that the 100 Hours bills are going to the floor on closed rules. Which should ensure that, whatever happens, they'll pass at least one house on schedule. (Though not necessarily without incident: the vote(s) on the OPI in the ethics bill, for instance, may split both parties.)

The danger comes with what comes next: the GOP will no doubt be looking to hold back the 100 Hours bills in the Senate (for the best of possible reasons, natch!).

There'll be other stuff going on; but the 100 Hours stuff is the marquee Dem product - and the bigger the circus to start the session, the bigger the embarrassment if the works get gummed up.

by skeptic06 2006-12-23 11:36AM | 0 recs
NEEDED: One Time Machine, New Or Used

So we can send all these jokers back to 1994/5, and they can tell it to Newt!
.
.
.

No egomania on that front, right?

by Paul Rosenberg 2006-12-23 03:55PM | 0 recs
I support Pelosi on this

I like that she is focusing on her roots.  I hope that the message gets through that the people are getting their Congress back.  

by MDMan 2006-12-24 02:59AM | 0 recs
Re: Pelosi's Long Inauguration is the Right Move

I feel WE should be in Washingotn, D.C. with OUR OWN major celebration, organized by MoveOn, true Majority, bloggers, labor and eco-groups.

We are missing a GREAT opportunity to celebrate and BE SEEN and heard by major media.  

Conservatives made a MAJOR presence in D.C. after their first election victory (summer of 1978), after having defeated an incumbent Republican in the primary with one of their own.
They basically introduced themselves to the U.S.

by dogenman 2006-12-24 03:01AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------