Why is Pelosi so powerful?

Since I can't think of anything timely to blog about today either, I'll put down some thoughts on Nancy Pelosi, who I haven't always liked.  Nancy Pelosi has a huge amount of clout and influence within the Democratic caucus, and I see it there are three pillars of her power.

  1. IDEOLOGY: She's a progressive, and that means she's trusted by one of the largest caucuses in the House.  As annoying as it is to have the Blue Dogs and the New Dems meeting with the President and carping about the need to be friendly to business, it would be nearly impossible to manage the caucus if progressive members were unhappy with the leadership.  They like Pelosi, and that's her powerful base.
  2. MONEY: She's a great fundraiser, bringing in more cash to Democratic challengers in 2006 than any House member.  She comes from cash-rich California, and she can just bring in money.
  3. JUDGMENT: She has very good and respected political judgment.  It's little known that in 2005, it was her call to not offer an alternative plan to Bush's Social Security privatization scheme.  Not only did she go against the advice of pollsters that Americans wanted a solution to the Social Security crisis, she aggressively squelched rival plans, including one from Rahm Emanuel. At the time, the strategic question within Democratic circles was whether to oppose Bush's plan directly or offer an alternative.  She made the right call, and she enforced it.  

Pelosi isn't always going to make the right decision, and it's going to be very difficult to manage this caucus.  But she is well-respected by House members for her tenacity and grit.  I saw it up close on net neutrality, when she was one of our big champions.  This is someone you want on your side.

And she's now our leader.

Tags: Nancy Pelosi (all tags)

Comments

11 Comments

Has she said anything about Net Neutrality...

...since the election?

by EricJaffa 2006-12-15 11:34AM | 0 recs
Pretty fair assessment, I'd say

Pelosi has done things I thought were pretty poor judgement - but then, the moves that she made which were quietly effective would tend not to have come to my attention!

I don't think the Dems have anyone better (not that a Speakership election was ever a live possibility).

And she clearly wants the gig. Which, as you say, will be a difficult one.

And, for the next couple of years at least, all her moves, good and bad alike, are going to be dissected in some detail.

Can't wait.

by skeptic06 2006-12-15 11:39AM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

I don't think the netroots have given Pelosi a fair shake yet.  A lot of the complaints about caucus unity, resistance while in the minority, etc. were either overblown or mostly out of her control.

I have just two complaints:

1) When she's been attacked in the media, she hasn't had surrogates out there to defend her.  In particular, some of the overtly sexist attacks need to be called what they are - sexist.  Not having a better defense only reinforces the stereotypes.  She's the first woman speaker of the house ever, and second in line for the Presidency.  She deserves a bit more respect.

2) The Reyes appointment. I'm glad she passed over Harmon and Hastings, but it turns out this guy doesn't know the difference between Sunni and Shia Muslims. WTF? The single most important qualification for anyone in intelligence is having at least a basic understanding of the workings of the Muslim world. I mean, geeze, we gotta have higher standards than the Bush administration on this.

by fwiffo 2006-12-15 12:02PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

Completely agreed - how f-ing embarrassing.  Someone needs to pull every single elected Dem into a room and explain the difference.  If they don't already know, keep them on the back bench.

Reyes' ignorance along with his appointment are unacceptable.

by Karatist Preacher 2006-12-15 12:08PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

"The Reyes appointment."

True, but it illustrates another problem -- notably that Reyes was the 3rd person mentioned for the job.  How far deep into the bench can she go? And whom would you pick?

I'm the only one here who believes this, but I had no issue with Harmon myself

by v2aggie2 2006-12-15 09:53PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

She's showing that she's a serious person with serious goals.  She's made it plain that we will have a no-nonsense congress with zero tolerance for corruption.  I think that most everyone will agree with her call for a 5-day congressional work week. I  also think that everyone will agree with the elimination of earmarks. Pelosi presents a businesslike image, which contrasts very favorably with the lazy, corrupt house that she inherits. I'm sure she'll make some mistakes, but her instincts are good, her politics are good, I think even Repubs see her as a breath of fresh air.

by pdefalla 2006-12-15 12:51PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

The media likes to make Pelosi some woman scorned who carries grudges. A quick look at candidates and their donations to the DCCC shows that beyond the alleged snits and even the policy differences, Nancy Pelosi watches the campaign warchest with an eagle eye.

She can count.  And she acts on this.  Look at the people she gets along with in leadership or near leadership positions.  They all are enough of a team player to make big donations to the DCCC in the last two years (2005 and 2006).  The people on the outs are not team players and make no pretense in hiding it.

DCCC donations by House member for this cycle:

Emanuel  650,000
Pelosi   635,000
Hoyer    620,000
Frank    476,000
Clyburn  470,000
Murtha   410,000
Rangel   385,000
Slaughter320,000
Kennedy  275,000

Tauscher 90,000
Harman  190,000
Meehan  125,000
Jefferson 20,000

All of these individuals gave separately to candidates, other House members and (in many cases) other organizations.  Dollar Bill had a lot more in his freezer than he contributed.  Tauscher claims the "victory" and does little to make it happen.  We all know about Marty Meehan and the humongous stash of cash he left untouched (and grew bigger).

by David Kowalski 2006-12-15 02:28PM | 0 recs
It might have been her call...

...but she called it because WE the progressive blogosphere (which is the voice of progressive activism) made a good case for it.

And as you said, that ties right back into being trusted by the progressives.

She knows when to listen, when to take advice and when to go her own way.

by MNPundit 2006-12-15 03:09PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

Time magazine person of the year!  I hope.

by vwcat 2006-12-15 04:34PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

I was always pretty neutral on Nancy Pelosi.  Earlier this year the San Francisco newspaper ran a three part series profiling her.  After reading the articles, I was a fan.  I don't think you can read the articles without at least coming away with the feeling that she is pretty savvy.  The 1st article is at the following link.  Links to the other two articles are in the article.  Be forewarned the articles are fairly long.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f= /c/a/2006/04/02/MNGSHI24ON1.DTL

by pax 2006-12-15 06:48PM | 0 recs
Re: Why is Pelosi so powerful?

I think Pelosi has stayed true to her progressive roots, but at the same time, she has done a good job of reaching out to the Blue Dogs and making them feel that their views are not being ignored. I read an article in The Hill a year or two ago in which several Blue Dog members who had had reservations about her becoming minority leader were impressed with the job she was doing and said that they felt she had reached out to them and given them a role to play. I think that's a big part of her success - her ability to reach out to and unite various factions of the caucus without seriously compromising her own beliefs.

by democrattotheend 2006-12-17 07:59AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------