Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Net a Nine-Seat Gain?

I have updated the MyDD Governor Forecast 2006 and there is a real possibility that the Democrats will pick up nine governorships. That's right, going from a 22-28 disadvantage to a 31-19 advantage. Really.

DEMOCRATIC TARGETS

Republican Congressmen for open governorships in Idaho and Nevada are skating on thin ice, very close to losing races in which they were long favored to win. While I project both still as "leans Republican", it's not a very strong lean and the Democrats could take either or both of the seats. In the relatively safe and safe pick-up category, Ohio, Massachusetts, Arkansas and Colorado are looking more and more like locks for the Democrats (I'm not even going to mention New York), and Martin O'Malley in Maryland continues to hold a decent lead over GOP incumbent Bob Ehrlich. Minnesota might even be breaking for the Democrats. Rhode Island and California, blue states that both showed promise for the Democrats at some point during this cycle, are becoming stronger and stronger holds for the Republicans. And finally, Florida polling seems to indicate some tightening, though Republican Charlie Crist continues to hold at least a moderate lead.

Safe Democratic1. New York (Democrat: Eliot Spitzer).

Likely Democratic2. Ohio (Democrat: Ted Strickland). 3. Massachusetts (Democrat: Deval Patrick). 4. Colorado (Democrat: Bill Ritter). 5. Arkansas (Democrat: Mike Beebe).

Leans Democratic6. Maryland (Democrat: Martin O'Malley).

Toss-Up7. Minnesota (Mike Hatch).

Leans Republican8. Idaho (Democrat: Brady). 9. Nevada (Democrat: Dina Titus). 10. Alaska (Democrat: Tony Knowles). 11. Rhode Island (Democrat: Charlie Fogarty).

Likely Republican12. Florida (Democrat: Jim Davis). 13. California (Democrat: Phil Angelides).

Safe Republican (In alphabetical order, by state): Bob Riley in Alabama, Jodi Rell in Connecticut, Sonny Perdue in Georgia, Linda Lingle in Hawaii, Dave Heineman in Nebraska, Mark Sanford in South Carolina, Mike Rounds in South Dakota, Rick Perry in Texas (though the race should be interesting with two strong independent candidates), and Jim Douglas in Vermont.

REPUBLICAN TARGETS

The chances of the Republicans picking up one or more governorships this year are getting bleaker and bleaker. In Maine, where Democratic Governor John Baldacci is having trouble polling over 42 percent against Republican Chandler Woodcock, even the prescence of a strong indie candidate is not helping the cause. In Oregon, public polling shows Democratic Governor Ted Kulongoski with a growing lead. In Iowa, which might be the Republicans' best shot as the only open Democratic seat this year, Democrat Chet Culver continues to hold a small, though meaningful lead. And in the mid-western states of Michigan, Wisconsin and Illinois, Democrats continue to lead even as regional and local issues suggest they should be in trouble.

Toss-Up1. Iowa (Democrat: Chet Culver). 2. Maine (Democrat: John Baldacci). 3. Oregon (Democrat: Ted Kulongoski).

Leans Democratic4. Wisconsin (Democrat: Jim Doyle). 5. Michigan (Democrat: Jennifer Granholm). 6. Illinois (Democrat: Rod Blagojevich).

Safe Democrat (In alphabetical order, by state): Janet Napolitano in Arizona, Kathleen Sebelius in Kansas, John Lynch in New Hampshire, Bill Richardson in New Mexico, Brad Henry in Oklahoma, Ed Rendell in Pennsylvania, Phil Bredesen in Tennessee, and Dave Freudenthal in Wyoming.

For updated polling and analysis of all of this year's most important gubernatorial races, head on over to the MyDD Governor Forecast 2006 sponsored by Bill Richardson.

Tags: election forecasts, Governor 2005-6 (all tags)

Comments

12 Comments

Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

Good update, but...

You might want to take Butch Otter out of "Safe Republican" since he's now in "Lean Republican" territory.

by Phoenix Rising 2006-10-31 01:10PM | 0 recs
Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

Thanks. I had the ID race in leans GOP but forgot to move it out of the safe GOP list, apparently.

by Jonathan Singer 2006-10-31 01:46PM | 0 recs
Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

CA is a shame.

The fratricide during the Dem primary increased the negatives on the nominee and left him broke having to spend tens of millions in winning a pyrhic victory.

The governors are the crop from which we can harvest good presidential candidates and CA being such a large state ought to have a decent bunch of Dem governor candidates. I think this was a lost opportunity.

by ab initio 2006-10-31 01:14PM | 0 recs
Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

Term limits present a huge problem for Democrats in California.  It's difficult to build a political base when you can't stay in an office for more than 6 years.

Fratricide aside, Arnold received tons of support from the Hollywood liberals.

by MyDD Fan 2006-10-31 01:27PM | 0 recs
There's an interesting thing here...

...California would love to nominate "liberal" Republicans, because the state voting populous is very anti-tax, although liberal in almost every other way.

However, the state Republican party is screwed, because they keep nominating retarded wingnuts with no funding and no chance.  The Dems try to "help out" during the primaries as well (see Gray Davis and Richard Riordan in 2002, where Davis ran attack ads against Riordan, the moderate, during the primary, making sure wingnut moron Bill Simon won the primary, letting Davis cruise to victory in the general (yet get recalled less than a year later)).

Arnie is exactly what a lot of Californians seem to want.  But he would never be able to get nominated in a statewide race in a normal primary.  But in the crazy 100-canidate recall election, he was a shoo-in, and as the incumbent, he still is.

by Geotpf 2006-10-31 01:35PM | 0 recs
Democrats Net a Nine-Seat Gain?
Boy, am I looking forward to next Tuesday evening.
Have secured a major inventory of popcorn and beer, and have sent out invites to my political co-conspirators.  We will be all over the TV and the computer, probably until the very wee hours.
I'm in an undisclosed location in upstate NY, hopefully the early returns from out here in the East will be an indicator of good things to come across the nation.
by global yokel 2006-10-31 01:19PM | 0 recs
California

Not that it really matters, but California right now surely qualifies in the "Safe Republican" column.

(But here's to Villaraigosa in 2010!)

by Silent sound 2006-10-31 03:00PM | 0 recs
Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

I would put Florida into "leans republican."  There's some definite tightening and Crist did extremely poorly (and Davis fairly well) in last night's debate.  Plus, there's finally some ads running for Davis.  It'll be close, Crist may not be a foregone conclusion after all.

by beeswax49 2006-10-31 03:12PM | 0 recs
The party should have funded Florida and Nevada

Both of those races have the potential for frustratingly close losses. Perhaps avoided with more money. I think the party avoided those races due to popular outgoing GOP govs, and the assumption it attached to the anointed Republican nominee. Meanwhile, you got a goof like Gibbons, and last night Crist was so pathetic he didn't even understand what a voting machine paper trail is.

I'm in Nevada and the gripe here is moderate Jim Gibson would be winning the gov race handily over Gibbons if we had nominated him instead of Titus. Local political analyst Jon Ralston joined the crowd saying that today. In Florida, I know there were reports Rod Smith fared better against Crist than Davis did, in the I-4 corridor and in the panhandle.

That's one huge variable going forward, how our primary voters handicap the race. Obviously the most-electable tag was improperly applied to Kerry, and in swing states there is tremendous potential for nominating the wrong guy. Actually, it can work both ways. Ohio was such a mess for the GOP this year we could have gotten away with nominating a much more liberal gov candidate than Strickland.

Update on the Gibbons battery charges: the local media is wonderfully reporting the maximum jail sentence and fine that Gibbons faces. Today the Gibbons camp got a favorable ruling to  release the parking garage tapes. They will be handed out tomorrow and given to the media. Supposedly they don't show Gibbons or Chrissy Mazzeo and the Gibbons people are shouting vindication, but video surveillance experts say the type of system used may record at intervals, alternating cameras every 30 seconds or so. There were reportedly 11 cameras. Very possible the area where this occured was simply not recording at the time. Also potential the image was "burned in" to the tape. Cynics are wondering how the tapes didn't exist for two weeks, then miraculously show up and the Gibbons campaign is notified first. Gibbons' top advisor used to be a lobbyist for the firm that gave the videotapes to metro police.

by Gary Kilbride 2006-10-31 04:49PM | 0 recs
Re: Governor Forecast 2006: Could the Democrats Ne

First, lets not rehash the primary but its quite clear that Gibson would have been torn to shreds by Gibbons on precisely the issues that Titus beat him with. Plus he had limited support among the Dem base and would have had to spend all fall shoring it up, thereby ceding precisely the center where TItus is now competitive.

If anything, the gripe is that Gibson hasn't supported the Democratic ticket in any way.

But thats water long under the bridge.

As for Gibbons, thats interesting about reports of the sentence GIbbons faces etc. My sense of media coverage today is less sanguine; too much unsourced talk of the tapes and too much replaing of Gibbons self-pitying attacks on his victim on am right-wing talk radio.

Metro is trying to fend off claims that the tapes exonerate him, and I think you are right that after tomorrow's coverage of the court ruling, the next set of stories will be about the bizarre handling of the tapes, the prospect of incorrect, incomplete or doctored evidence.

The RJ will report poll results tomorrow that show Gibbons slightly ahead and that will lead to another round of stories about how he's holding on. But rumors are that more reliable polling is turning up results more ominous for Gibbons, if Titus and the Dems get the big edge in turnout they are hoping for.

But the real question I think is whether or not Titus can cut through the noise and get her case made; she's still got to give wavering undecideds or lazy dems a solid reason to go vote for her.

by desmoulins 2006-10-31 08:05PM | 0 recs
Poll rumor: Gibbons lead cut to 4

That's rumored on Las Vegas sites tonight. Mason-Dixon is overdue to release a poll and a former Las Vegas Review Journal political reporter is saying inside sources tell him it will show Jim Gibbons leading Dina Titus by 4. That's the closest she has been and I'm pleased by that number. No word what the exact percentages are, or number of undecideds.

Titus is going to have to explode the gender gap over the final week but if there are enough women among the undecideds it can happen. Mason-Dixon normally overstates Republicans in Nevada. Their final 2004 poll gave Bush a 6 point margin but he won by closer to 2.

I know I've posted it many times but we boneheaded this race by not funding it post primary. Jim Gibson, the nominee we rejected, was a far superior fundraiser to Titus, outspending her more than 2-1. If you're going to nominate the more liberal candidate in a state like this you've got to realize she needs help financially since the natural sources are lesser in number. Titus was basically off the air from the August 15 primary until late September, allowing Gibbons to relentlessly define her as Dina Taxes.

by Gary Kilbride 2006-10-31 10:13PM | 0 recs
Confirmed, Titus trails 44-40

I saw it on the Review Journal site but the link doesn't work.

The 44% confirms Gibbons' base number is plummeting. Eight percent undecided, and a mixture to third party candidates and none of the above, which we have in statewide races in Nevada.

by Gary Kilbride 2006-11-01 01:34AM | 0 recs

Diaries

Advertise Blogads


----------- myDD - skin -----------